M2T vs. MPG for HDV Capture?

Hello All,
What is a better option to capture HDV video via firewire?
1) Capture through Premiere CS3 into an MPG file?
2) Capture through Adobe On-Location into M2T files?
Are they essentially the same? Is there different compression? Are there compatability issues?
Background:
I have to capture about 25 hours of HDV video from a JVC HD100 in 720P30 format. I will have to share this footage with a couple of different people (sponsors, event organizers, etc).
For compatability, I have already decided to capture via firewire instead of through my HDMI or analog component capture card. I know that codec is rare and fairly cpu intensive.
I am just curious if M2T or MPG is preferable on a whole.
Chris

The file structure is actually the same. I don't know why some programs capture as M2T and then Adobe came after and captures as MPG. (On Location was purchased, not designed by Adobe).
They are the same and are interchangeable in Premiere Pro.

Similar Messages

  • Are there benefits to the Blackmagic Intensity Pro for HDV capture ?

    Are there benefits to the Blackmagic Intensity Pro for HDV capture ? 
    I have a Sony HDR-FX1 that records in HDV 1440 x 1080 
    I have already captured the footage to miniDV tape. 
    Can the intensity card get the full 1920 x 1080 video ? 
    I now use Premiere to capture my video and my HDV is in mpeg2 and my SD is in DV type 2 AVI 
    What format does the intensity card capture at ? 
    Are there other ways to capture that would make the footage better. 
    From what I have read allot of people have had problems with these cards. 
    Im just looking for the best way to get the footage off my camera with the best resolution. 
    Thanks:  Glenn 

    Glenn,
    I have posted this before in the PC Buying Guide (post #23 and later), but have a look at this diagram:
    The problem is that once recorded to tape, the material is compressed to MPEG and there is no way to get the data back, that were lost during compression. The only thing you achieve is that you lose device control, lose all timecode information, lose all metadata like date and timestamp and exposure data and lose the capability of scene detection. There are no gains to compensate the losses.
    Compare it to a glass of orange juice, that was made by heavily compressing oranges. How do you think you can reconstruct the original oranges that the juice came from? Were there 4 large oranges or 6 small ones or a mixture? Were they light colored or were they dark or a mixture of light and dark?
    BlackMagic in their marketing may lead you to believe otherwise, but the truth is they can only guess at how many oranges were used, their size and color. It is nothing more than a guess.

  • Correct settings for HDV capture

    Hi. I'm using Premiere CS5.5. I went on a few forums to get the correct settings for HDV capture.
    I can record the footage fine. However I saw a few things which didn't seem right.
    After capturing the HDV footage, the file was a .mpeg file. Secondly, the clip was 1 hour and 10 minutes and
    it was only 11.3 GB. Does this sound right? A 55 minute .avi file is 11.6GB. I thought a HDV clip would be quite a large size file.
    If this dosen't sound right, is there somewhere I could go to, to check that my settings are correct? By the way I'm filming and capturing with a Canon XHA1.
    The footage is 1080i. HDV. I've exported it and it looks fine. Just want to make sure I've captured it correctly and to the best quality.
    Thanks for your help.

    The HDV format was advanced by Sony and others to use the same miniDV tapes used for SD.  In fact, your Canon XHAI can record and play either without changing the tape transport speed.
    Your observation in relative file sizes is due to the fact that HDV is highly compressed (MPEG), whereas, SD (AVI) is not as highly compressed.  This is one of the reasons folks (such as Harm) don't consider HDV to be an edit format, but just a delivery format.
    Note that what Harm was saying is symantics--you capture an analog source through a capture card that digitizes it.  When you transfer a image file from HDV or SD, it is already digitized, so a bit-to-bit transfer occurs.

  • "Lacie Rugged" for hdv capture?

    Is the 160gb 5400 rpm buss powered drive good enough for basic hdv capture and editing?

    I'm not a big fan of the larger 3.5" drive based Lacie units, as Shane already pointed out, they have a very poor record for reliabilty ....
    ... the "Rugged" however, one of their smaller 2.5" format drives, is an excellent little drive, very robust and in my own experience its very reliable. It will be more than adequate for HDV capture and editing.
    Note: if you are not travelling regularly and do not need the added peace of mind of the big rubber bumper then there is little point in spending the extra money on this one, there are plenty of alternative drives that are equally reliable AND that have 7200rpm drives inside for that extra oomph when you want it.

  • No preview for hdv capture window

    When I try to capture hdv I am not getting a preview of the footage in the capture window while browsing the footage. I realize that I will not get a preview while capturing but I should get the preview while just browsing through the footage yet all I get is a black screen. I do have full control of the camera via premiere and the captures do actualy work. This used to work fine with cs3 but stopped working with cs4. The regular DV capture works fine with the preview. Its a sony fx1 hdv camera. Also when I click on capture setting nothing happens but if set to dv capture the capture settings give me options including preview settings.
    Thanks in advance.

    Well, it's actually a sad shortcoming of Premiere CS4.
    I'm new to PPro, and CS4 is my first, in fact I'm new to video. What little I know, I've been doing with Final Cut.
    So the answer to your question is actually "it's by design", hence my commentary.
    Ref: http://help.adobe.com/en_US/PremierePro/4.0/WS00B136B2-33DB-49a0-B247-6521242FDBDAa.html
    On the Mac, it's actually worse - HDV capture preview is totally non-existent.
    http://www.macworld.com/article/136525/2008/11/pprocs4.html
    It's a minor annoyance for me, and it could still "grow" on me - since video isn't being transferred to PC while previewing, there is no perceived delay, and the keyboard shortcuts, I and O, are the same (with FCP).
    Landed on this post after searching for what I thought was a capture setting problem, and also found the above links that answered it for me. Hope this helps.

  • JVC HDV Capture settings + Hardware advice for HDV capture

    We have 6.02 FCP Studio2. We shot JVC HDV 720 60P footage (1280 x 720) and are trying to capture thru FCP. We have the JVC GY-HD200U camera and the JVC BR-HD50 outboard deck. Other than the AJA HD 422 device, what are my options (hardware and software) to capture with Log & Capture in FCP? I need In/Out points of course.
    JVC HDV says it has a great HDV workflow in FCP, but they don't tell you how (at least where we have looked on their website)
    Unfortunately, Blackmagic's Intensity Series cannot control the devices via the HDMI link (One HDMI output is on the JVC BR-HD50 deck). We thought that might work.
    Can anyone give us advice on the settings in FCP to control our HDV deck or Camera? We would prefer to keep everything digital, via firewire
    Thank you everyone for your help. I did search for this topic and found nothing. I am sorry if this has already been covered...

    Connect your deck or camera via firewire to your Mac, and then select the easy setup in FCP's FCP menu that matches the format you've shot. I'm pretty sure for a device control setting either your camera or deck would use HDV Firewire Basic as a device control setting. Other than that it should use the stock preset for the format you've shot.
    Jerry

  • HDV Capturing Problem.

    Hey,
    I'll start real quick by getting to the point and stateing my problem.
    When captureing HDV 1080i tape footage, it just stops randomly
    after about 4-8 clips. Different each time. Heh.
    Now I'll give you some information on my equipment, ect...
    Computer
    Windows 7
    Intel Core 2 Duo CPU T6400 @ 2.00HGz (2CPUs), ~2.0GHz
    4 GB RAM
    NVIDIA GeForce 9600M GT
    Software
    Adobe Premeire Pro CS5
    Hardware
    Sony GV-HD700 Digital HD Videocassette Recorder
    Boss usually gives me just regular DV footage to work with.
    This time he's given me an HDV 1080i wedding.
    1. I set up my project...
    2. Set Capture Footage to HDV.
    3. Set my Scratch Disk.
    4. Set Sequence Presets to HDV 1080i30 (60i)
    5. Set my Tape Recorder to HDV (instead of DV that I usually work in.)
    6. Here's a picture of my capture screen letting me control it,
        but not letting me Record.
    7. Click Settings and switch over the DV and capture it, just to see if it works. It
        does but its only in 720. So basiclly didnt work. Derp.
    8. Look around some more and find somone saying to go to the Tape Recorder,
        and change the i.LNK CONV to OFF. I do that. Also set my capture device
        to Sony, Standard, because a guy said it worked for him with the same Tape
        Recorder I have. Also because GV-HD700 isn't even available.
    9. Open Capture again and Record button shows up. Yay right? No. I hit record
        and it dosent really capture anything... Dunno why. It plays the tape on the
        recorder but dosen't capture. Here's a picture...
    10. So then I I'm like, what does this Tape Button do?
    11. Make sure I have Scene Detect ON. Then I click TAPE.
    12. Then it starts captureing footage! Yay right? Heres a picture..
    13. Everythings going great. I can't see the footage on my screen, but that doesn't
         seem to be a big deal. The footage is playing and I can see clips captureing.
    Then it just Stops. Just Stops captureing. The tape keeps playing. But no more
    captureing. What is the problem here? I'm out of ideas and I don't know what to
    do anymore.
    Hope someone can help me out.

    Try this for HDV capture http://strony.aster.pl/paviko/hdvsplit.htm
    Do you have at least two hard drives?
    My 3 hard drives are configured as... (WD = Western Digital)
    1 - 320G WD Win7 64bit Pro and all program installs
    2 - 320G WD Win7 swap file and video project files
    3 - 1T WD all video files... input & output files
    Search Microsoft to find out how to redirect your Windows swap file
    http://search.microsoft.com/search.aspx?mkt=en-US&setlang=en-US
    Trying to use only ONE Hard Drive for Video Editing
    You are a music conductor, with a baton that you use to point to various parts of the orchestra... this is like Windows pointing to various parts of the hard drive to do Windows housekeeping or to load program segments for various functions
    Now, at the same time and with the same hand... while still using the baton to conduct the orchestra... pick up a bow and play a fiddle... this would be doing something with your video file at the same time as all the other work
    You as a person cannot do both at the same time with the same hand
    A computer is a LITTLE better, in that it can switch from one kind of task to another very quickly... but not quickly enough for EASY video editing
    You need AT LEAST two hard drives (separate drives, never a partition http://forums.adobe.com/thread/650708?tstart=0 for more) with Windows (or Mac OS) and software on your boot drive, and video files on a 2nd drive so the boot drive is not slowed down by trying to do everything
    I find that the three drives I use work very well for me, for editing AVCHD video... some people use a 4th drive, so video INPUT files are on drive three and all OUTPUT files are on drive four... I only bought a mid-tower case instead of a full tower case (my bad... but had to fit in the space available on my office desk!) so I use the three drives that will fit
    Depending on your exact hardware (motherboard brand & model AND USB2 enclosure brand & model AND external hard drive brand & model) AND the type of video file, you may... or may NOT... be able to use an external USB2 hard drive for SD (Standard Definition) video editing
    Steve Grisetti in the Premiere Elements forum http://forums.adobe.com/thread/856208?tstart=0 and Jim Simon in the Premiere Pro forum http://forums.adobe.com/thread/856433?tstart=0 use USB externals for editing
    A USB3 hard drive connected to a motherboard with USB3 is supposed to be fast enough for video editing (I don't have such, so don't know) but eSata DOES have a fast enough data transfer for video editing... I have not used this eSata Dock... for reference only, YMMV and all the usual disclaimers
    http://www.amazon.com/Thermaltake-BlacX-eSATA-Docking-Station/dp/B001A4HAFS/ref=cm_cmu_pg_ t

  • Sony Z1U HDV Capture Settings for FCP 6.0

    Hi, I am shooting a project on Sony's HVR-Z1U HDV camcorder at HDV 60i NTSC. Does anyone have suggestions for settings to capture the material into FCP. I have FCP Version 6, part of the FC Studio 2 upgrade.
    Appreciate any feedback!

    There are definiitely some advantages to editing in DV rather than HDV for easy workflow and faster renders, etc.
    To capture, you'll have to get the settingns on the deck and in FCP to match. If you have the deck/camera set to HDV then choose the appropriate easy setup in FCP such as HDV 1080i60. If you want to capture as DV, then set the deck to downconvert to DV, and choose the DV NTSC easy setup. You'll want to check the anamorphic box for you capture settings and sequences, but keep in mind if your are working with DV or any SD format, that the anamorphic setting can be esaily applied to clips and sequences after creation or capture.
    When you export your web clips with compressor, figure out a square-pixel frame size that is some multiple of 16:9.

  • When I try to import files from iMac HDD into the event, it fails. FCPX dosn't see this files for import. Files are *.m2ts and *.mpg. Should I buy plagin Quicktime component MPEG-2 to resolve a problem?

    When I try to import files from iMac HDD into the event, it fails. FCPX dosn't see this files for import. Files are *.m2ts and *.mpg. Should I buy plagin Quicktime component MPEG-2 to resolve a problem?

    no you should transcode those files into an format that os suitable for editing. Like proRez. Although you might need some Flip4Mac or perian or something to do the conversion.
    adam

  • HDV captured create movie for iDVD, lot of jitter and jagged interlace play

    Not sure what I'm doing wrong. I wanted to downconvert from HDV capture / edit, and then just create a standard video dvd for normal tv playback. Picture looks like it will be outstanding, but any movement results in horrible jitter and jagged edges. What am I doing wrong?

    Wow thanks for quick reply. Apologies I didn't give full info.
    I am viewing DVD on TV - well a plasma being played via DVD on PS3.
    BUT, DVPRO50 is the only output that shows a "smooth" movie, if I playback on the canvas at 50% the interlace line are gone due to the scaling BUT the movie plays jumpy, so the DVPRo50 method is the only way I can get a smooth pan for example, every other method just gives a jumpy playback on DVD.
    iDVD is set to Production quality, when I do a QT movie direct to iDVD without the DVPRO50, the quality is better but the movie is jumpy.
    The movie is also 47 minutes long - it's quite big, file produced is about 19GB.
    Also I understand about getting HD quality and BlueRay disk etc, but I would expect to get DVD quality from iDVD, doing the DVPRO50 conversion makes it pretty bad. but smooth!
    As I said the anooying things is when I exported to MP4 on quicktime at 1080 HD and 18000kbps and 29.97 it also plays smooth for a short bursts of a few seconds (albeit jumping every second to 25 -> 29.97 issues), in 25 fps it's just blurry and jumpy. (playback on PS3)
    Thanks

  • Very slow capture for hdv

    Hi
    I bought a Sony Hd camcorder, the Sony Hc7.
    It transfers using HDv.
    I attempted to start making a movie with the footage shot on this camera in Final cut Pro Hd but it wouldnt read it as my version was pre support for HDV.
    However the new version of Final Cut Express would read it and so I bought that. It does capture the footage but very slowly, a 30 second clip previously would take 30 seconds to capture.But now it takes about 1 minute to capture.
    Is this a function of
    1) Using Final Cut Express and not Pro?
    2) USing HDV, is it always this slow compared to standard Def?
    3) My Mac power? I have a G4 with 1.5 ghz Powerpc and 1.25 gb ddr sdram and about 50 gig in internal memory and the scratch disk is set to my external drive with 638 gigs of spare memory.
    Any suggestions? I am not keen on buyng a new machine until Apple bring one out with a bluray drive.

    It sounds as if it is converting HDV to AIC.
    What computer are you using?

  • Firestore vs. Citidisk for HDV - is it true DTE?

    I'm very curious about purchasing a Firestore or Citidisk external drive for HDV recording. They both claim to be Direct-To-Edit technology, but I'm concerned about having to transcode the footage from a .m2t file (I'm not sure what kind of file this is) to edit in Final Cut, thus negating the time the device is supposed to save. Basically, I haven't been able to find any posts from consumers who have either of these drives, are using them to record HDV, and can immediately edit with them in FCP 5. Is it possible? I'm assuming the device would have to record a native Quicktime HDV file. Am I wrong about that?
    I'm shooting with a Sony FX1, and am also curious which drive is better. Citidisk seems the much better deal, but I've heard the quality of the device is questionable. Any thoughts? Any advice from people who are recording HDV projects with these boxes?

    I hate google. I love google.
    http://www.computervideo.net/may04-6.html
    http://www.eventdv.net/Articles/ReadArticle.aspx?CategoryID=50&ArticleID=11291
    In addition, the CitiDISK also properly handles parallel recording on both the tape and the hard drive at the same time. Many camcorders now feature the ability to control external recorders, including decks and hard drive units like the CitiDISK. The CitiDISK started and stopped each time I hit the Record button on my FX1. Every time I switched from DV to HDV on the camcorder, the CitiDISK's lights would flash and blink and eventually the power would shine a steady green. The transition time varies in proportion to the amount of hard drive space the unit has. I am told the 120GB models take about 15 seconds.There has been some discussion online about whether the CitiDISK can play back HDV clips to a connected camcorder. My unit could not. It could only play back DV clips via QPlay. While not as capable as the FireStore FS-4 Pro HDV, and lacking the interactive data screen, the CitiDISK HDV 100GB is currently about $700 cheaper than an 80GB FS-4 Pro HDV model.Because the CitiDISK uses the FAT32 filesystem that enables cross-platform connectivity, the video is automatically chopped up into 988.5MB files that are about four-and-a-half minutes long (the FireStore models use the same system but allow 2GB filesizes of 10 minutes of 25Mbps DV or 1080i HD2; you'll get a couple more minutes from 19Gbps 720p HD1).
    This file-chopping necessity results in a plethora of numerically sequential names that are created automatically. There is no "pre-naming" in case you need to shoot multiple projects on the same drive. You will work with CLIP0106, CLIP0107, etc. It will change to the next hundredth digit (0201, 0301, etc.) on its own and not based on any natural turnover, camera action, or time of day that I can discern. In the end, though, the clips are sequential, and a drag-and-drop into the timeline should order them properly from beginning to end.Another curious situation arises when dragging all the clips into an FCP bin. They all appear as clips that have lost their link with the source files. Selecting them all and then relinking them takes a few seconds. It doesn't happen if I use the menu to "import" the folder of clips—only when I drag all of them together from the Finder.
    I do have an issue with the clips acquired on the CitiDISK. I set it to record MOV files for FCP, but the files recorded appear with 16-bit, 38Kbps audio as opposed to the 16-bit, 48Kbps audio that they should have. FCP can play a single layer of these, transcoding the audio on the fly, but it is not able to mix multiple layers of stereo audio on the fly as it can with 16-bit, 48Kbps audio.<
    <a class="jive-link-external-small" href="http://">http://www.macaddict.com/issues/2003/3/reviews/citidisk
    http://www.videomaker.com/scripts/article.cfm?id=10957
    http://digitalvideoediting.com/articles/viewarticle.jsp?id=50479
    Why use tape if this disk takes care of everything for you? Connectors are a tricky thing and I’ve found during tests of this and other HDD recorders that if the connection is lost, so is the video. Best to have a back up than nothing at all. If the connection to the camera (or computer) is lost, all three of the lights on the front of the CitiDISK will flash to let you know there is a problem. If you want to risk it, you can manually start and stop the record process.
    The CitiDISK captures in Raw DV, Windows AVI2, QuickTime MOV, and M2T for all HDV footage at a sustained 12MB/second. While having the M2T is great, Final Cut Pro does not natively recognize the format. You will have to use a conversion utility to do that. Not a big deal, but it does increase workflow time.
    Because the CitiDISK is compatible with Windows and Mac, the drive is formatted as FAT32, which means files will have a 2GB size limit. If you record over the size limit, CitiDISK HDV will automatically create a new clip sequentially numbered.
    To do a quick check of the video captured, CitiDISK HDV has a Quick Play function. By switching the camera to VCR mode and pressing QPlay users can spot check their work with ease.
    But don’t be fooled, the CitiDISK HDV drive is a barebones system. There are no transport controls during Quick Play. There is also no way to tell exactly how much time remains on the drive. Instead the system resorts to changing the color of an indicator light. While it is helpful, when the light turns red, the user still has no way of knowing if there is 20 minutes or 5 minutes remaining.
    This lack of control feedback is the biggest disappointment for me. It is really difficult to remember all of the button combos that need to be pressed to get certain desired results. Also when first starting the system, all of the lights blink randomly for about 15 seconds. For a new user, this could cause them to think there is something seriously wrong with the unit. Unfortunately the manual, while thin, is too wide to slip into the belt-clip case, so the best bet for users is to take the Ron Popeil approach and set it and forget it.
    I also ran into a problem during my testing that my Mac failed to recognize the captured files on the drive. The PC found the clips without a problem. I could transfer the files to my PC then network to my Mac. I ended up having to reformat the drive using Shining Technology CD that came with the unit and all was well.
    Even with the capacity to record nearly 8 hours of footage, the enclosed rechargeable battery will only last about 90 minutes, which makes it pretty short for most long form events.<
    <div class="jive-quote">Re: Citidisk captures HDV as m2t How do I convert? NEW: Re: Citidisk captures HDV as m2t How do I convert? Aydin Odyakmaz <[email protected]> -- Wednesday, August 16 2006, at 10:49 a.m.Thanks for the tip. I did upload the Streamclip and for some people it is important to know that you need to have the Quicktime mpeg2 component which should be available with FCP, but mine wasn't working , so I just went off and paid the $20. I am just wondering if this workflow is going to take just as long as dumping the footage direct from the camera as converting it with Streamclip?
    Thanks Aydin<
    bogiesan

  • Why HDV capture in FCP 6.0,3 is not as clear as original footage?

    I have tried several capture's settings for HDV footage captured in Sony HDR-HC7. Once it is in my computer's hard disk and ready to strt editing it seems that the video is not very clear mainly the edges of moving objetcs look if they were a liitle bit "dreagged". I ve been told in the Final Cut Training course that the defect is only possible to be corrected in Color program . It fact it is reduced a little when the filter "Film Look" is applied but it does not look as good as the original footage. Is there something I should need to do?. Thanks

    #2 Blurry Playback
    Shane's Stock Answer #2: Blurry playback
    ONLY JUDGE THE QUALITY OF YOUR MATERIAL ON AN EXTERNAL BROADCAST MONITOR, OR AT LEAST A TV.
    The Canvas shows you what happens after the codec you are working with has been applied. The Viewer shows you the material in its native format. Once you drop the footage from the Viewer into the timeline, it inherits the attributes of the sequence. If it is a DV sequence, the footage will render out as DV.
    1. Disable overlays on the Canvas.
    2. Make sure you've rendered everything (no green bars at the top of the timeline).
    Video playback requires large amounts of data and many computations. In order to maintain frame rate and be viewable at a normal size, only about one-fourth of the DV data is used in displaying the movie to the screen. However, the DV footage is still at full quality, and is best viewed thru a TV or broadcast monitor routed thru your camera or deck.
    NOW...seeing that you are working with HDV, the only way you are going to be able to see the actual quality of what you have, you will need an HD capture card and HD monitor. Matrox MXO plus Apple Cinema Display is a cheap way to go, works with laptops. Or if you have a MacPro, then the Decklink Intensity and HDTV would be a good inexpensive choice. other than that...www.aja.com www.decklink.com
    Shane
    Shane

  • 5.1.4 update breaks HDV capture? Unable to Initialize Capture Device

    Problem:
    Final Cut Pro cannot capture standard 1080i60 HDV footage from Sony FX1 camcorder. FCP reports "Unable to Initialize Capture Device" when the log and capture window is opened. However, the footage CAN be captured in iMovie (which is interesting, and unacceptable). When HDV>DV downconvert option on camcorder is activated, footage CAN be captured as anamorphic SD, so the camcorder and FW do work.
    The problem is occuring on a rock-solid FCP system that I use on a regular basis (mainly for SD editing). It has been approx 2 weeks since I last attempted a HDV capture, the system has been working great with SD footage (still does).
    Factors that have changed to my knowledge since HDV capture was last functioning properly:
    *Added a new external FW drive into regular usage (a different brand than normally used, no issues with it so far).
    *Updated FCP to 5.1.3, and then 5.1.4 when that fix came out. All SD captures and work have been fine so far.
    Here's what's interesting...I had a copy of the FCP v5.0.4 .app that I had saved an archive of prior to the crossgrade update. Guess what? I can load it up, and it captures HDV without any problems! With that in mind, this looks like an FCP 5.1.4 issue. But I am at a loss on how to proceed further in troubleshooting. Many thanks in advance for any assistance.
    Matt Jeppsen
    FresHDV.com
    ---NOTES---
    What I have tried:
    *Attempted capture with a different Sony FX1 camcorder.
    *Swapped firewire cables and system firewire ports.
    *Attempted capture with camera FW chained to an external HDD.
    *Unplugged all other external firewire devices from the system.
    *Trashed FCP prefs using FCP Rescue 5, created new project using Easy Setup (for HDV).
    *Tried different variations of FCP A/V settings, tried all the HDV FW device control presets and the HDV AIC capture preset.
    *Per instructions at http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=301852 I removed the numbered Quicktime pckg Receipts and re-installed the latest version (7.13). Post-install/reboot, I repaired Disk Prefs and Verified the disk using Disk Util.
    *Have also attempted installing QT 7.13 2 and 3 times in a row, also trying disk prefs repair BEFORE the post-install reboot.
    Final Cut Pro Audio/Video Settings:
    Sequence Preset: HDV-1080i60
    Capture Preset: HDV
    Device Control Preset: Sony HDV Firewire
    Sony HDR-FX1 IN/OUT REC settings:
    *VCR HDV/DV: HDV
    *COMPONENT: 1080i/480i
    *i.LINK CONV: OFF
    *TV TYPE: 16:9
    *A/V->DV OUT: OFF
    System/Software Facts:
    *Final Cut Pro 5.1.4
    *Quicktime 7.13
    *PPC Mac G5 2.7 Dual (2.5GB RAM)
    *35GB free on System, 45GB free on internal FCP Scratch disk
    Final Cut Pro 5.1.4, G5 DP 2.7 (PPC) Mac OS X (10.4.8)

    I think I figured out this vexing problem. I too was having the same issue. Check to see that your Quicktime is newer than 7.1.2. If it isn't you'll have to upgrade it. I only upgraded to 7.1.6 here because I was afraid of going to a really new version. http://www.apple.com/support/downloads/quicktime716formac.html. After I upgraded my quicktime, I ran software update and the Final Cut Pro 5.1.4 update appeared. I hoipe this helps.

  • Sequence settings for HDV 720p 24 fps

    Okay, now that the French is gone I'm back on track, but still confused. I've captured my HDV 720p @ 24FPS footage using LumiereHD & it's separated & ready to go. What sequence settings/editing timebase should I use? I've noted people here saying DVCPro, but others said DVCPro is just problemic/not correct for HDV . . . and the Lumiere forum reccomends using the Apple Intermediate Codec, which I think people here said NOT to do . . . and there's a 720p24 option in Lumiere, but not in FCP . . . is it just like using 24p DV where you edit at regular 29.97? My head is turing into goo. Any sage advice, O sage ones? And I'm finishing on DVD, if that's usefull. Thank you!!!

    Don't stay nervous for ever, you're missing out on a lot of good stuff.
    1. Repair Permissions.
    2. update to OS X 10.4.8
    http://www.apple.com/support/downloads/
    3. update QuickTime to 7.1.3
    4. make sure you have Motion 2.1 already installed
    5. update all your pro apps with Software Update
    http://www.kenstone.net/fcphomepage/whats_new_5.1.2balis.html
    http://discussions.apple.com/message.jspa?messageID=3213777
    Still nervous?
    I can't tell you what setting in FCP 5.1 to use, because I no longer have 5.1.
    I would convert the HDV to DVC PRO HD 720p.
    Editing in native HDV is a pain because of the frame structure.
    You will end up with larger files with DVC PRO HD, but since it's all "I-frames" editing and compositing will be much, much faster.

Maybe you are looking for