Sub Contracting in FIFO Valuation Method
Dear All,
I am facing one serious problem while using Subcontracting Addon.
We have developed Sub Contracting Add-on based on Standard Valuation Method and it is working fine.
But when we use FIFO Valuation method then it will not allow.
So could you please guide me the process/procedure how to implement Sub Contracting in FIFO Valuation Method.
Means what are changes needs to make it success in FIFO.
Thanks
Vikas
Hi
Yes its right not to change the earlier valued items on one costing method to another.
Imp. to note that, for manufacturing/sub-contracting the best costing method is Standard. Because, in manufacturing processes, its very much impossible to track the exact in and out of material as per FIFO; costing method comes into picture as you made some inward and outward or some movement of material, i.e. in case of purchasing material FIFO starts acting as you start consuming the materials or you transfer the material from one warehouse to another, other than in which you have received the material. When you have material on floor, its quite impossible to track the exact movement of material, means which material is actually being processed on the floor. So, If we use FIFO for such items, then actual costing will be always different from executed/system costing, Also, FIFO is suggested for only those business practices who are following the JIT principle. But, by having Special as costing method for manufacturing items, we avoid such problems to have actual costing, though it may again differ from actual costing, but overall as per the business experience we come to know COGS to actual basis.
In Special Costing method, it's recommendable to revise the Standard cost of the items, periodically.
Similar Messages
-
FIFO valuation is not updated by system
Hi,
We have activated FIFO valuation and all configuration was set. We done MIGO with different rate and Consumption also done.
Month end we have don e the following process
MRF4,MRF3 and MRF1
the result is system is taking the moving average price only instead of FIFO valuation.
Goods Receipts
Qty price value MAP
100 100 10000 100
150 120 18000 120
200 180 36000 180
450 64000 142.22
Issues :
100 142.22 14222.22 142.22
150 142.22 21333.33 142.22
250 35555.55 142.22
200 0 28444.45 142.22
As per FIF the following is the rate system to take and post
200 180 36000 180
But system is takinf 200 * 142.22 = 28444.45
can anyone guide me to solve this issue.
govind.HI,
check if you hve set the "single receipt" flag in your FIFO valuation method (T-code OMWP). For explanation whats the difference if the marker is set or not see
http://help.sap.com/saphelp_46c/helpdata/en/47/6106f949f011d1894c0000e829fbbd/content.htm
Check also the "tolerances" setting in MRF1, maybe its made in a way that the FIFO result is not taken into consideration but the material price is taken instead.
BR Christian -
Change valuation method from moving average to FIFO
We have incorrectly given valuation method for our raw materials to moving average instead of FIFO. Now, we have a lot of transactions and cannot change the method after a transaction is done for any item. I want to know if this solution will work:
1. create new database with item and business master data, chart of accounts, item groups as before
2. change valuation method of all items
3. Import GRPO, Excise and A/P invoices from old database
Does step 3 create its own JEs?? If it does, then my problem will be solved.Hi Krishna,
this is the SAP Business One Forum in German. Please post your threads in English to the forum here:
SAP Business One Application
All the best,
kerstin -
541 & 543 Mvt for Sub Contract Process with Split Valuation
Hi all,
We have activated SPLIT VALUATION for sub contracting in ECC 6.0
We have clasified into 3 Valuation Catergories as New,Repaired & Faulty.
The logic & naming convention of the materials are
New Material : C1
Repaired : C2
Faulty : C3
The details are as.....a faulty material can be converted into Repaired by the external Vendors,for which we raise a PO and do MB1B with 541 mvt type with ref to this PO.
The Acing Entries are
PK GL Code Material Value
99 117000 C3 10
89 117000 C2 100
93 600530 90
While in process the GR w.r.t the above mentioned PO ,we are getting 6 accounting entries (which is delivered by Stand SAP) they are as
PK GL Code Descrip Value
89 117000 Stock 100
96 117400 GR/IR 150
91 600530 Sub Cont 100
86 600863 Sub Service 150
99 117000 Stock 100
81 600530 Sub Cont 100
Can any please explain me how the system calculates the above Accounting Entry.
We are confused why the system calculates ( entries) for the 91,81,86 Posting Key.
I have uderstood that PK 89 for goods inward, 96 is for GR/IR clr, 99 is for reversal of 541 mvt type.
Other 3 entries i have the confusion ........
Can anyone please guide me and explain in detail how ,why andfrom where the system is calculating the entries.
Hope that you will help me in this regards
Take Care
God Bless
Regards
Praveen.
Edited by: Praveen Singh on Sep 16, 2008 8:07 PMGo to OMWB and click on simulation and here enter you mateirla number, plant and Mtype 101
Then click on account assignment
you will see all the entries
Posting Lines Text VlGCd AGC VCl PK Acct D PK Acct Cr
Gain/loss from revaluation -e- -e- -e- 83 440700 93 440700
Inventory posting -e- -e- TRA1 89 130000 99 130000
Incidental costs of external a -e- -e- -e- 86 460820 96 460820
External activity -e- -e- TRA1 86 460960 96 460960
Change in stock account -e- -e- TRA1 81 460820 91 460820
Purchase offsetting account -e- -e- -e- 40 --Missing- 50 --Missing-
Purchase account -e- -e- -e- 40 --Missing- 50 --Missing-
Materials management exch.rate -e- -e- -e- 40 440600 50 440600
Cost (price) differences -e- TRA1 83 440000 93 440005
GR/IR clearing account -e- -e- TRA1 86 210005 96 210005
Inventory posting -e- -e- TRA1 89 130000 -
my client running fg sub contracting (electro plating )cycle through the MRP
after return from vendor with mvt type 105 (543) i check document list with MB51. i found following g/l account effects :
SFG consumption for sub contract account = 602026
Gr/IR Clearing Account = 164335
SFG-inventory account = 323055
for sub contract account = 602130
Inventory account = 320010
Costs of goods mfg = 602200
but if do whole sub contracting cycle without MRP i can see effect in following G/L a/C:
Manual Cycle .
Inventory account = 320010
Gr/IR Clearing Account = 164335
Price Differance Account = 602155
change in stock = 603010
Sub Contract expense = 603000
SFG-inventory account = 323055
SFG consumption for sub contract account = 602026
my question is why this differance comes ?
if i want gl accounts hit by manual process in MRP process what changes to be made ?Hi,
Price diffrences arise during valuation @ GR if the material is managed at standard price in MMR.
Also there is one more setting in customizing that for a plant that price differences should or not be posted during GR.
spro-IMGMMInv MGmtGR--price differences for subcontracting at GR
Regards,
Deepak. -
Sub contracting Process issue for A/c entry
Hi All,
While doing the GRN for subcontracting process ,cost object error is appearing for stock change SFG account ( BSV).
Business would like to do not assign the Default cost object for change in stock account. Kinldy confirm whether it is possible to determine Internal order number ,whcih same assigned to GRN for stock in change account SFG.
Any alternative method would be apprecaite
Rgds
SumaManiThanks to all of us for answers !!
We solved problem as mentioned !
1. Created separate SFG Stock change over subcontracting GL account and assigned same in OBYC - BSV & profit centre wise internal order defaulted in OKB9 settings.Also created sub contracting expenses GL and assigned OKB9 profit centre wise. ( Problem has been solved with separate GL account of stock change over)
It can be possible to solve with using of substituion GGB0 with module pool RGGB0*
Rgds
SumaMani -
Dear All,
While making GRN for sub-contracting by using 543 movement type, the following account determinations are made as per the messages received in process.
GBB--VBO FOR VALUATION CLASS 7900
WRX--GR/IR
BSV--CHANGE IN STOCK
FRL--FOR EXTERNAL ACTIVITY
But I am getting error message as
Fld selectn for mvmt type 543 / acct 24110499 differs for Cost center (010)
The above acc no was assigned to GBB--VBO.
Please provide a solution.
Regards,
Venkat.Hi
The problem may be because the field selection of GL account 24110499 from FI is different from that for the movement type 543 from MM. The Report RM07CUFA can be used to check this discrepancy. Therefore, go to Transaction SE38 and select this program. The next screen will appear where you have to enter both your G/L Account and Movement Type and stock indicator O.
For further information, check in OSS Note 9281.
regards
Srinivas -
GL account doesnt exist in company code-error in Sub contracting PO.
While doing GR for the sub contracting PO, I am getting this error for line item 4: GL account 490237 is doesnot exist in company code 0600.
3 line items are already recieved to the GL account 490223 which is correct.
for 4 th line item when i am going to do the GR the above error is occuring,
I have checked the FRL setting for Valuation grouping code VB01 with 490237; it should be acually 490223.
Where can I see the changes relevant to that, all of a sudden GR is asking for the new GL account than the one which use to posted earlier? Pls help me experts.
Thanks
SriThe correct G/L account is 490223, so far posted with. what changes went to production I dont know
Valuation grouping code in obyc is VB01 490237 (at present for FRL)
VB02 490223 (at present fro FRL).
due to which all of a sudden its looking for 490237 which is not correct.
after our EHP5, is this got changed to vice versa?
Thanks
Sri -
How to select the Alt BOM in the Sub-Contract PO
Dear All,
please tell me how to select the alternative BOM in the sub -contracting purchase order.
for the above said requirement i have cretaed production versions and the BOMselction method also i have selcted in the material master data as "2" means BOM by produ ction version.
so how can i select the alt BOm in theSub-contracting PO.
Thanx in advanvce
regards
SrinivasHi,
SAP help says you have to write the production version in the subcontracting info record:
http://help.sap.com/saphelp_46c/helpdata/en/b2/fa1ed4d51d11d1a69e0000e83235d4/frameset.htm
http://help.sap.com/saphelp_46c/helpdata/en/35/b0e96787a62488e10000009b38f9b7/frameset.htm
(I've checked a subcon-info record but sorrowfully I havent found a field for this...if you can find please let me know)
BR
Csaba -
Sub-contracting: difference in Accounting
Hi guys,
I am using release 4.7 and we are discussing about 2 different ways to proceed sub-contracting.
1. Sub-contracting is handled only in MM: PR>PO>GR
2. Sub-contracting is handled as an external operation in routing:
Prod.Order>PR>PO>GR>Confirmation of Prod.Order
In particular we would like to understand the different impact these two ways of managing Sub-contracting have in accounting especially in Cost of production and in cost of goods sold.
Could you kindly give me some clarifications?
Thanks in advance
VirHi Sunil,
there is a particular thing I forgot to say that is Material Ledger. In my company we implemented it and all stock materials are managed with standard control key.
So at the end of month there is Variances Analysis and Distribution to materials with multi-level strategy.
What I want to know is if both methods of Sub-contracting fullfil the requirements of cost of production and cost of goods sold reconciliation .
Your precious answer is grateful
Vir -
Dear Gurus,
We have two manufacturing units,one is an EOU(Export oriented Unit) and the other NON EOU unit.
We get an export order (subcontracting order) for the EOU from a client in country X. Some of the processing is done in the EOU, and then sent to the Non-EOU.
How can I map the material movement between the two units?
Note: The material is maintained as a non-valuated material in both the plants. Since it is maintained as non-valuated, we cannot create a sub-contracting PO when sending the material from EOU to Non-EOU plant.
Regards
RamHi,
I think you are speaking about two subconracting POs:
- one subcontracting PO was issued by your client to your company
- second subcontracting PO is becasue your company manages the production between the business units --> I think you are asking about this
Do the business units belong to the same company code (intra-company process)? If yes, there's no point in speaking about subcontracting.
Re: plant to plant subcontract
Even if it is inter-company (cross-company) process you shoul be able to send non valuated material (component) to special stock (OSS note 80267) via subcontracting PO or you can use STO (as in case of intra-company).
Please specify your question if my answer is not relevant.
Regards,
Csaba -
Sub Contracting Operation Problem
Hi frnds,
I'm facing problem related with GL Account.
Dears I'm going to create Automatic Purchase Requsition for material which is manufactured Externally by Vendor but the RAW Material is given by us means I want to create Sub contracting PO and only paid service prices for manufacturing the material to vendor. For this
1. I create the PIR through TCODE ME11 with material
2. Maintain the PIR in Master Ricepe with Cost element.
3. Create Process Order & PR is generated but
When I trying to convert PR to PO, it show Error message that the assign GL Account is not correct at
the field Account Assignment.
I want to know at Account Assignment what GL Acc. will come to enter.
ParminderHi,
Hope the Acct *** Cat in the PR is F - Order Assigned PR.
pls try this out.
1. In OLME , check the Acct Modification key - say , VBR for the Acct *** Cat - F (Order)
2. In OBYC , pls check whether the Cost Element (say,400000) you have entered in master recipe is
mapped against - GBB - VBR - Valuation Class Combination.
Also ,pls let us know the Cost Element that you have entered in Master Recipe.
Regards,
Sheik -
Result Analysis Valuation Method 3
Hi PS Experts,
The building block document on Profit Realization 'I58_BB_ConfigGuide_EN_DE' says that as per IAS 11 and 18, we need to configure Result Analysis Valuation Method 3 only which is cost based. Is it right and whether you are all having this valuation method in your SAP system where IFRS standards are applicable.
Then, in addition to this cost based Revenue Recognition through this valuation method 3, we would like to input realistic POC(Engineer's certificate) into the system. Whether it is possible and if so, how and what other valuation method we need to use with or with changes to a particular valuation method. Appreciate your valuable inputs on this.
Regards!Hello,
Cost based POC i.e Method 3 is compliant with IFRS requirements. Other methods also are so.
The choice of RA method depends on value/risk/duration/revenue plan of the project. We use this method for high value projects running for a long time where there is a need to recognise revenue before actual billing.
Completed contract method is also used and very much in accordance with accouning principles.
For POC calculated through progress determination- say Engineer's certificate- you can use method 7.
Thanks, -
Dear All
Is it possible to Change the valuation method from FIFO to LIFO or Moving Average Price, when the Stocks are available in factoryStandard to MAP and vice versa are very well explained in the document provided by Ramana on page 31. Thanks Ramana!
As far as the FIFO and LIFO valuation are concerned, the system continues to maintain in standard or MAP, as setup by the price control indicator, S or V. What the system does is, at the period end, finds what would be the value of the closing stock, if FIFO or LIFO is method is followed. It is only relevant to valuation of closing inventory. <b>It is for information purpose</b>, but still if you want to value the inventory on FIFO or LIFO basis, then <b>you can set up the update indicator</b>. If it is done so, then the value proposed by LIFO/FIFO analysis is updated, <b>as if it were a price change.</b>
In OMWE you can <b>parallely maintain both LIFO and FIFO</b> active. -
SUB CONTRACTING ACCOUNTING ENTRY - DOUBT
Hi,
the blw is the a/cing entry for the sub contract process , here pls tell me how the a/c detemination for Rs 1000 is picking i.e for BSX & BSV..
i knew that FRL & WRX picked based the po price say Rs .200
and GBB & BSX is picked based on the mat master value of the ram mat, which we send to subcontractor.. say Rs 800
i need to know , how the BSX and BSV value is picking?? pls clarify
BSX- stock account finished -
1000(+)
BSV- change in stock -
1000(-)
FRL-external service----
200(+)
WRXGR/IR clearing acct--
200(-)
GBB_VBO- consumption acct raw material sent to vendor-----800(+)
BSX- stock account--
800(-)in your case , Your Finished material is valuated at MAP with price control "V" , so the total value of material produced will be the sum of the Raw material components consumed and the subcon charges.
Change in stock account is hit when you receive any material from subcontracting .
so BSX entry is "Stock debit " 800 +200 = 1000 (sum of Components consumed and Subcon charges)
BSV Entry is for "Change in stock " credit = 1000 (equivalent to Finished material value)
Maybe you are looking for
-
Problem logging in to MOS with Opera
I'm on a Mac running Lion 10.7.3 using Opera 11.61 with Flash version 11.1.102.62 and am having problems using the actual My Support site. For instance, backspace doesn't work in text entry fields; if I type wrong I have to mark the text with the mou
-
Hyperlinks are dead when Pages file is exported as a PDF
When I export a file from Pages '09, version 4.0.5, to a PDF file, the hyperlinks do not work. The Pages help menu states "Hyperlinks in your Pages document are exported to the PDF file. Hyperlinks are also created in the PDF file for table of conten
-
SetRendered(false) not working in ProcessRequest
hello, in the (R12) Update Bank Details page of MY HR i am trying to render the AddDeposit (OAF ID) button to false, programmatically. Initially i want to do this 'as a test', but later want to put some conditions around it (if it works) I have exten
-
Switch to BT Mail has deleted all my sub-folders
I have just moved from BT Yahoo to BT Mail, following the instructions BT provided. On my PC I use Windows Live Mail. Previously, all my (thousands of) emails were organised into numerous sub-folders dropping down from the Inbox tab, so I knew where
-
I have edited a lot of video clips and titles. Now I have unwanted test in two titles. When I try to edit tie titles, they look fine. How do I get rid of the unwanted text?