Best Workflow; HD to YouTube, iPhone, and DVD?

Hi there. I'm currently editing a four and a half minute video in Final Cut Pro, which was shot on HDV 1080i, 30fps. To review my work, I've been exporting the timeline using the Apple ProRes 422 (HQ) 1440x1080 30p 48kHz setting. This creates a very beautiful, clear looking file, albeit a little large (roughly 4.5GB).
I am going to need to export my video to three places; YouTube, iPhone, and burn on DVD. I was wondering what the best workflow for each of these you recommend.
I'm completely unsure about YouTube, though I imagine for iPhone I could take the 4.5GB Quicktime file in Quicktime and do a File->Export using the Movie to iPhone setting. This would theoretically create the best quality file for iPhone, correct?
Further, I know I could use Compressor to create .m2v file ready to burn on DVD using DVD Studio Pro, but what settings do you recommend? Since the video is so short, I would want the maximum bitrate, but don't want to set it so high that some DVD players can't play it. Thanks SO much in advance!

I do basically the same thing you do, except at 24p instead of 30. My workflow for going to Youtube uses a pair of custom-crafted Compressor presets. First, I scale my ProRes 422 HQ reference movie down to 640x360, still in ProRes, with frame controls on. This gives me a really good downrez.
Then I encode the resulting downrez to H.264 at 20 Mbps, with AAC audio at 256 Kbps. (Sometimes I have to tweak the bit rate of the picture to keep it under Youtube's one-gig hard ceiling. I recommend BitRate Pro for this; it lets you calculate the bit rate needed to encode a show of arbitrary length to a file under one gigabyte.) This is the file I upload, on the theory that giving them all the bits possible will result in the best possible final encode to Flash.
The last step in my workflow is to stab the person who wanted me to deliver via Youtube.

Similar Messages

  • Best workflow for burning Blu-ray and DVD

    Hi,
    What's the best workflow for effciency sake for burning both a Blu-ray and a DVD of the same project?
    Essientially I'd like to export and create a menu once, then be able to downrez to DVD. However, I'm not sure that is possible since blu-ray and DVD are differnt codecs.  
    Thank you

    The only way that you can get acceptable re-scaling of menus is to go from BR to DVD, and do the editing in Photoshop.  Simply re-scaling the menu here will not give acceptable results.
    I usually copy the various button layers from the BR menu to a new DVD menu file created using the provided Photoshop preset.  You will still have to do  some manual re-scaling and alignment.  The thing that has given me the most trouble over the years is round button highlights - a segment is often chopped off.  Font sizes will probably need adjusting too.
    Unless you are adept with handling layers and groups within Photoshop, it may be easier to start again.
    Any attempt to convert within Encore is unlikely to produce acceptable menus in my experience.

  • BEST Workflow? MPEG-2 Cutting and preparing for DVD...

    Hi all
    I am in the process of putting together a showreel. The only way I can get my work on a DVD is to record the DVB-T Stream (its Swiss Television), which Quicktime says is "MPEG2 Muxed, 720 x 540 Pixel" - and it's with 25fps.
    Now I'd love to cut those Files in FCP with as high quality as possible and export it for DVD-Studio. If I would not be cutting these files, as I already did last year, there is not much conversion but only demuxing needed to use them in DVD Studio.
    But how can I cut those MPEG-2 in FC Studio 2 without much quality degredation?
    Whats the best workflow for this?
    I read somewhere here in that forum, that I have to convert this into DV, cut it in FCP, and then convert it again to MPEG-2 -- but that sounds like a lot of compression going on...

    Thanks for your reply Shawn.
    Im aware of the fact that a recompress is not the best way to go. But I don't have any other chance, since a broadcasted signal is already in MPEG-2 and there is nothing I can do about it, this is my only available source. There is no tape for me.
    I was basically just wondering if there is something like a smart Compress..say, it only recompresses where there have been changes, between two I-Frames... and evrything els thats unchanged just get copied. that would be the way to go...
    Message was edited by: loop 66

  • What's the best workflow for Home Movie Importing and Enjoying?

    I'm new to iMovie (and the mac) and have started importing all my home movies from my camcorder into iMovie. I quickly realized that movies take a huge amount of disk space and it may or may not be reasonable to import all my movies and keep them on the hard disk in .dv format. At 12GB/Hour I would need 1.2 Terabytes of storage (plus backup). If that is the best workflow, i'm happy to invest in a few terabytes of storage and back up. But before I do that, I want to check to see if there is a different workflow I should follow given my use case.
    Here is my use case:
    I have 100 hours of 8mm and miniDV tapes already and plan to continue creating more.
    I want to import them all into the iMac for ease of organization, searching for the clips of interest, and watch them either on my iMAC and also on my TV (via TIVO).
    I may do some editing, but this is not a big priority for me at this time. I may do more editing in the distant future when I have more time. My editing for now will be limited to rejecting portions of clips I don't want.
    I plan to watch the movies from my iMac on my TV via my TIVO (i've already ordered the Roxio Toast software that I understand I need, per the Tivo web site).
    The final piece of my use case is back-up. I'd prefer to back up my movies on disk this way I maintain any editing i've done in case of a disk failure. Depending on what video format is recommended, this may bump me into a RAID multi-terabyte system as both working and automatic backup?
    Here are my questions:
    Should I maintain my event library in .dv format? (and bite the bullet on the storage)
    Or is the .dv format intended only for temporary editing and users are expected to compress into another format after editing? if so, what format and which tool is recommended? (keeping in mind that I want to view the clips via Tivo and Roxio/Toast).
    If I need to byte the bullet and invest in storage, my quick math suggests I'll need about 2 terabytes for the library and 2 more for back up for a total of 4 terabytes!?. Is a RAID system recommended for this? (I was surprised that the Apple store did not carry such a system, so perhaps that is not the best option). What would you recommend?
    Anyone out there with a similar use case? I know I've asked a lot of questions here. I'd appreciate any recommendations you may have, even if you cant answer all of them.
    Thank you.

    I am in a similar mode, though about half as much existing DV footage.
    +Should I maintain my event library in .dv format? (and bite the bullet on the storage)+
    Short answer, yes; long answer:
    I did "bite the bullet" since 1T drives are at or just over $100. I'm using a MacBook Pro so I bought an 2 port eSATA card for my cardbus slot ($34), and a 1T eSATA/Firewire/USB drive ($119). I don't plan to "back up" as I am not going to get rid of my Mini DV tapes/vhs/analog tapes, etc. Those will be in an off-site dark cool closet elsewhere. I don't want to do RAID or such as it still puts everything in the same drive unit, in the same location. Basically I'm splitting my video import to two different physical drives. So if lightning, thieves, personal incompetence or whatever strikes, there's more chance it'll only affect one of the drives. I've thought about a Drobo, which you might consider. It is unique device that offers a spin on RAID that offers some advantages.
    Everything I read here on these boards suggests that it is best to grab the source video in the original format whenever possible. Since storage is cheap, makes sense to me.
    It is likely you wouldn't compress your video unless you were going to edit it. For example if you wanted to make a video of the kids growing up to give the relatives you'd likely end up compressing to burn them a dvd. You would compress if you were going to use MobileMe, YouTube, etc. to post some footage. Whether you watch the video from home, or output to DVD for others, or post online, at least you'll have the source video in it's best possible original format to work with.
    This is an aside, but might be useful, I imported one tape at a time, let iM09 create a new event and split per each day. THen I renamed every event based on what the content was before doing the next tape. This really helps later on once yo realize you have a hard drive with 50 hours + of everything in your life on it. I included the year in the name in some way, for example, John's wedding 1994, Hawaii 2000, Hawaii 2004. Then I ended up drag/dropping Hawaii to one event.

  • Best Practice for update to iPhone and iTouch

    OK, when 3.0 comes down the pike, what is the best way to get 3.0 as a "clean" install? Currently 2.2.1 is on both. If I do a restore, will the system only pick up 3.0 or will it see 2.2.1 which is currently on the hard drive? With that in mind, how can I delete the 2.2.1 version of the iPhone and iTouch software? Sorry for two question in one post.
    Steve H

    When firmware update 2.0 was released, the entire iPhone was eraseed first including the existing firmware - just as when restoring an iPhone with iTunes, followed by 2.0 being installed, which was followed by the iPhone's backup being transferred to the iPhone.
    The same may apply with firmware update 3.0 with your iPhone's backup being updated immediately before. If not, firmware version 2.2.1 will be updated with 3.0.
    If 2.2.1 is updated and you want a "clean" install of 3.0, you can follow the initial upgrade by restoring your iPhone with iTunes.

  • Best workflow for footage in 1440x1080 and vid rate 23.98fps going to a PAL DVD player in europe

    I am new at this and still getting a grasp of the technical details.  I've made several trips to Germany over the last three years and each time have shot using different settings.  Right now I am editing the footage from the first year where I shot 1080i and 24p (Canon XHA1).  I've already sent some DVDs with films I edited from this trip, but not sure I've achieved the best result that I can in terms of image quality.  What i think i've been doing so far is to edit in the original NTSC, and then when i get ready to burn the DVD to send to my relatives in Germany, I have set the Project Info settings in iDVD to PAL.  But from reading the boards I am getting the sense that there are multiple ways to do this, each with varying results.  Obviously, I'd like to have my German viewers view a DVD with the best quality picture, and am wondering what is the best way to go about this.  I've also read on the boards that most PAL dvd players will play NTSC, which makes me wonder if burning the DVD with iDVD set to PAL is necessary.  I've already been told by one of my relatives who has viewed the same film here in america (burned as NTSC) and in Germany (one I sent burned as PAL), that the PAL versions did not have as good a picture quality.  Any suggestions?
    Also, if you knew that your primary audience was going to be PAL viewers, and you are shooting with an NTSC camera, what would the ideal settings be?  On my canon xha1, my frame rate options are 60i, 30f, and 24f.  My 'comp out' options are 480i and 080i/480i.  My understanding is 1080i50 would be better for PAL, but 25fps is not an option on my camera.
    Thanks,
    Paul

    Well it must be 24 over 29.97 then because it is working with it.  I have been able to create timelines and export quicktime movies, etc.  The item properties (in FCE Browser) of the clips definitely say 23.98fps-- as I would expect because I know I had the camera set to 24p.  However, the frame rate of the sequences i've been editing on say 29.97.  This is without me having made any conscious effort to manipulate any settings for the sequences at the outset-- I didn't even know the sequences had settings for this when i started.  I just began dragging and dropping footage out of the browser and it must have automatically set the sequence to 29.97.  Who knows what I had the Easy Set up set to when i brought the footage over from my camera two years ago.  I knew even less then.  Are the settings on Easy Set up critical when bringing the footage onto your computer from your camera?  What processes are the Easy set up settings governing?
    Even with all of that said, you would recommend burning the DVD as an NTSC?  An NTSC in a new PAL DVD player will look better than an NTSC burned as a PAL?  I suppose I could send them both versions and see which one looks better.
    Thanks for you help Tom.
    P.S.
    On the true 24p issue, I did find this:
    There are many posts out there about the Canon XH A1 not having "true 24p".
    I think much of that misinformation out there maybe stemmed from (correct me if I'm wrong):
    Canon Frame Mode on the standard DV cams was a "simulation: of the 24 frame look.
    The Canon HDV 24p actually records each single frame progressively, but using an interlaced method.

  • What's best workflow for adding subtitle to existing dvd?

    We have been requested to add a foreign language subtitle to an existing dvd. It was authored in DVDSP so we have the original files. The translators are requesting a QT or dvd with window dub of the timecode for timing. How would I do that if the assets are already encoded and in the DVDSP timeline?
    Also, the project is setup on 5 tracks, many short chapters in each. Because the cost for translation is per file, it means we pay the minimum charge for each track which ends up being double than if we would have kept all the files on a single track. Other than re-authoring the dvd is there another way to do this and save the money. If I get a stl or son file of a long video stream can that file be broken into separate files for each of the tracks? Also looking for a better workflow for the future.

    rshellhammer wrote:
    ...we have the original files. The translators are requesting a QT or dvd with window dub of the timecode for timing.
    Take the file you used in Compressor to make the mpeg and make a mov file h.264 I believe will maintain the timecode.
    Also, the project is setup on 5 tracks, many short chapters in each. Because the cost for translation is per file, it means we pay the minimum charge for each track which ends up being double than if we would have kept all the files on a single track. Other than re-authoring the dvd is there another way to do this and save the money.
    No.
    If I get a stl or son file of a long video stream can that file be broken into separate files for each of the tracks?
    Not without a lot of work.
    o| TonyTony |o

  • Best workflow for Canon 7D (progressive) and Canon HX-A1s (interlaced)

    I have been doing 2 shot interviews using the Canon 7D and Canon HX-A1s. What is the highest quality and most efficient workflow in 29.27 fps with the 7D being progressive and the XH-A1s is interlaced? I have been converting the 7D footage to ProRes 422 (HQ).
    What Capture Preset is best for HX-A1s and Sequence Preset for radiating?
    Your help would be most appreciated.

    If you have the space, capture as ProRes....you can do that via firewire. If you are short, then capture as HDV and just work with it with a green render bar over the footage, and render later. Mixing formats is pretty easy as long as your sequence settings are ProRes.
    And your interlaced camera will take on a progressive look. If you are OK with that.
    Shane

  • Thoughts on BEST COMPRESSION for use with iDVD and DVD Studio Pro...

    Hi all...
    I'm having an issue with some visual artifacts that are present after burning a dvd using either idvd or dvd studio pro.
    My sequence containts footage (h.264) and photographs with titles. The photos (w/moves) look great, very crisp. So do the titles.
    However, the video looks awful. Pans and tilts creating streaking, so does any action with the frame.
    I don't see this streaking while viewing in the qt window or when previewing the dvd...
    I'm exporting as a qt reference using the dv/dvc pro setting, when I check the dvd on an ntsc monitor, the image is very streaky.
    Any ideas?
    Thanks,
    Mark

    Are you using FCP?? Then I see why you said QT reference movie... which is the best way. Being more descriptive about your setting when posting a question will return more helpful answers. (editing tool, source materials, machine spec...etc) You said that your footage was h264 and you posted your question in iMovie forum so I couldn't have guessed FCP and DV...
    If your sequence is DV on FCP I can't think of anything else but QT reference movie route. I don't understand why your video won't show interlacing in QT player or DVD preview, but perhaps they force deinterlacing for preview, who knows.
    You said your DVD looks 'very streaky' on ntsc tv. Is it to the point that it looks unnatural? Is overall motion jerky? If so, perhaps the field order had been messed with and changed. But I'm not quite sure about the exact nature of your problem. Visual problem in a subjective verbal description can be hard to communicate

  • Best Workflow for HD content onto a DVD

    Hello to you all out there! Here's what I'd like to do...I want to be able to burn HD footage onto a DVD, but still watch it as HD footage. I know that DVD resolution is MUCH lower, and am looking for a workaround for that. So what I need help with is:
    1. What settings am I looking for as far as my export from Premiere CS5.5?
    2. What settings in Encore?
    Thanks in advance!

    Fortunately BD disks are not that expensive any more. Philips 10 disks are for $10, Titan BD 10 disks are under 10. Blu ray burners are under 100 dollars on newegg.
    So my point is, if the stuff is affordable,  why to go thru hoops and humps and complexity to create BD disks, if it could be done just the way it is meant to be done? Unless you have a lifetime supply of DVDs, or hard core DVD fan.

  • Best iMovie settings for YouTube Upload and HD Playback

    Hello, I've tried using the various online suggestions for obtaining the very highest possible quality playback of my HD videos when I upload them to YouTube and...frankly...have not noticed any difference between using simply the 1080 export option and then uploading them into YouTube.
    Well, of course, the fact that going through the QuickTime export option takes a lot more time and creates a file that is huge.
    So, what is the consensus?
    Is shooting HD video on a HD camera and then importing and exporting from iMovie's automated settings really resulting in appreciably lower quality in YouTube HD playback?
    Would appreciate any thoughts on this.

    There are YouTube presets in Adobe Media Encoder. Just choose H.264 as the format and then choose one of the YouTube presets.

  • Best Way to Set Up iPhone on New MacBook

    I just purchased a brand new black MacBook!!!
    What is the best way to get my iPhone and all it's info on my new Mac?
    I currently have everything in my iTunes on a PC laptop.
    TIA

    Welcome to a new world. There will be a learning curve with some aspects but once you get past this you probably won't look back. One thing is not having constant virus, adware and spyware concerns which is a big one. When Apple came out with iWork 08 which includes Pages (word processor that is compatible with Word), Numbers (which is compatible with Excel) and Keynote (which is compatible with PowerPoint) with all three being compatible in both directions - you can save documents with all 3 to be compatible with their Windows counterparts, I've been completely Microsoft free since that time.
    I always tell my long suffering Windows using friends about the differences but what sums it up is this. I've always used a Windows PC at work and I get my work done but not once have I ever looked forward to turning on a Windows PC for anything. I always look forward to turning on my Mac even when work related and you will probably experience the same. You will really like iLife - using iPhoto to store all digital photos which is similar to iTunes for digital photos and with GarageBand you will be able to easily create your own custom ringtones with non-DRM protected music which an option to store the finished product in your iTunes library automatically as an available ringtone to be transferred to your iPhone.
    I think you will be very happy and satisfied with your decision and you won't need to be buying a new computer every 2-3 years or so unless you want to. I have a TiBook that I purchased in the spring of 2001 that is still going strong. I'm unable to install Leopard on this Mac but it is running Tiger without missing a beat.

  • I have two Iphones and haven't set them up in itunes properly so mine and my wifes phones are basically using same library ect, my wife now uisng my apple ID password for some reason, want to start again, Help

    I basically want to start again with two iphones, I know I need to set up itunes on two different accounts on my windows 7 pc, I've done this now but its too late, help help, btw I have no idea about iphones really.

    If you have your wife under a different account you will need to get her a new Apple ID, then sign into that ID. Then sync her iPhone in iTunes, note the apps that your have under your Apple ID on her iPhone will not update unless you sign in with your Apple ID and password, if would be best if she erased her iPhone and re-downloaded the apps under her Apple ID. For her to start over, make sure that her pictures and movie files are backed up, then go into the settings>general>reset then tap erase all content and settings.  

  • Best workflow for premier 13 and how to produce dvd's?

    Hi all.
    Historically I use imovie, idvd, and a little final cut express.
    My machine is a 2008 iMac recently upgraded with a new HDD and more memory, now 6GB. It is intel.
    Primarily I did this due to final cut not working my camera not recognised etc, but i discovered this is not ow supported in Yosemite.
    All is now well with the imac.
    I bought the elements bundle from Adobe and am getting to grips with the video editor just now also the organiser.
    I have loads of archived movies from the imac upgrade i did saved on and external HDD which I tend to try to use rather than filling the imac HDD up, although not so much an issue now with 2TB.
    I am working through my old footage and using a combination of imovie and premier  elements, to produce a final movie.
    My question is, what is the best workflow, I am going on a trip of a lifetime this year and want to practice the best workflow.
    I currently have files all over in various formats, so its a nightmare.
    Also what is the best way to produce a DVD?
    I used to produce movies with imovie then when i had a few I would produce a DVD with a few menus and buttons and movies on.
    This doesn't seem to be so straight forward anymore, I have tried to save a elements movie to a .mov and .mpg file to import to imovie then idvd but the aspect was changed to 4:3 for a start, so I may give up on that.
    I intend in future to download the files from cameras to folders I can recognise, although I have historically downloaded straight from camera, it would be a new method for me.
    What is then the best way to then produce my DVD's, I am not into blue ray as yet.

    Hello, Brian,
    What are you trying to burn...movies, photos, data???
    Whats the best & easiest way to burn DVDs?
    Are you using iDVD? It is the easiest way to burn a DVD. You need to have your video on your computer, usually imported into iMovie and then you create your DVD by putting your movie into iDVD and burning your disk.
    Have a look at this support section from Apple. Do all the tutorials and explore all the options. You will learn quite a bit and should be able to burn DVDs after that: http://www.apple.com/support/idvd/
    is there anyway to rip video from DVDs?
    If the DVD is a home-made one, you can copy it. Follow the directions from Dan Slagle via Silly Rabbit's post and also Matti Haverli's in this thread: http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?messageID=1642959&#1642959
    If it is a commercial DVD, it may not be legal to rip it. There are web sites that will give you info about how to do it.

  • Best workflow for Blu-ray/DVD projects

    For most of my encore projects, I end up creating a blu-ray and dvd version of the project.  What is the best way/workflow to do this?  I always seem to end up running into problems.

    Unless you are working with a high end pro format, Pro Res 422 is perfectly fine to use as a master file. PR 4444 is PR HQ with an alpha channel so you probably can save a lot of space and speed up your exports by dropping down two levels.
    If you use the BluRay prests in Compressor, it should do a very good job of encoding. Perhaps Toast is recompressing your file. I don't use the software but I think there is a setting simewhere to avoid the second compression.
    Or have FCP make the BD directly.
    Russ

Maybe you are looking for