Compositing Motion Output at highest quality

We are producing an animated trailer for our film.
There's a Motion-generated snowstorm in the background and Motion-generated 3D words that fly over head.
Each individual element looks great in Motion (great crisp edges), but when the indivdual elements are mixed in FCP, it looks as if it loses its pristine look.
I tried it a number of different ways. In the latest, I have the actual "motn" files right on the FCP timeline. The FCP sequence is set to animation. It still does not look as good as it does in Motion.
I was hoping to output a master file from FCP in Animation, and then transcode it for playback using ProRes.
Please offer me advise on a workflow, so the output can look as good as the canvas in Motion
By the way, you can see the final version of the movie I am talking about on this site (click the "See the Preview Film" link
http://believethemiracle.com/
This version is compressed for the web of course.
Using the latest versions of FCS
Thanks!

This may help:
http://www.kenstone.net/fcphomepage/motion_text_in_fcpspencer.html

Similar Messages

  • Compositing Motion output files

    Hi all-
    I asked a question and many chimed in, but the answers didn't quite rectify the issue. I re-read my post, and I think the issue could have been better explained. Here goes:
    We are producing an animated trailer for our film.
    In Motion, we created a snowstorm (Motion project file #1) and a 3D words that fly over head (Motion project file #2-7).
    The quality of each of these files looks GREAT when viewed in the Motion canvas on my 30" Studio display at 100% (great crisp edges).
    I outputted each of the motion project files to a quicktime movie with an alpha channel using the ANIMATION codec set to 100%
    The quicktime files, when viewed in quicktime look great -- just about as good as they look in the Motion canvas.
    Now I need a solution to composite all of these ANIMATION quicktime files into a movie.....Final Cut, right?
    So I did that and here is the result:
    http://rccm.org/longago.jpg
    The top image is a still exported from quicktime using one of the individual motion project files
    The bottom is a still exported from FCP after the composite...
    WHERE AM I GETTING THIS HORRIBLE LOSS?
    I've read the article on why images look bad on the FCP canvas, but the lower speaks for itself when compared to the upper.
    HOW CAN I BEST COMPOSITE THE QUICKTIME FILES?
    Here's our workflow
    1) Create in Motion
    2) Output each element to a ANIMATION file
    3) compile all output files in FCP (in a 1920x1080 sequence using the Animation codec at 100%)
    4) Output from FCP using (????)
    Using the latest versions of FCS
    Thanks!
    Many thanks!

    OK....I changed the Field Dominence (in FCP's Sequence settings) to Upper (odd) and it now looks good.
    I tested the output.
    I checked and rechecked -- I am outputting from Motion with no field dominance.
    I'm glad we found this solution...but why is this happening???
    Steven

  • What's the best way to output a high quality ready to send to the printer PDF?

    I'm designing a photo book for a friend and we're having output issues. We're working with a professional printer but for some reason our prints keep coming out soft or pixelated. The images are 300 dpi and formatted correctly for an InDesign document so the issue is likely output.
    What's the best way to output the HIGHEST quality PDF you can out of InDesign? Everyone seems to have different answers.
    Thanks in advance!

    Check a couple things.
    One would be for broken links. If there are broken links then ID will use the preview image instead of the linked image.
    Another would be to select an image that prints poorly in the Links Panel and check the effective resolution. If it is below your stated 300 dpi then the image has been enlarged greater than 100%.
    Then just use the PDF/X-4 profile for your PDF.
    Mike

  • Quickly create 8 minute highest quality DVD with no menus from Motion 4?

    What's the fastest/simplest way to create a high quality DVD without any menus that just plays from Motion 4?
    I set quality to best.
    I just tried using Share, and I can see one of my processors working at 100%, but I've got no indication of any progress - or even that it is working, except I can see a few files in the directory I told it to create them in.
    I told it to create a DVD (there was a checkbox), so I put a DVD in the drive.
    I have no idea how long I should wait until giving up? I'd generally avoided trying to send anything to Compressor from motion, as it would take 10x longer.

    Heya Les,
    For the quickest method at the highest quality I would export a self-contained movie from Motion and take the self-contained QT movie and bring it into Compressor. Because SD DVD is compressed to MPEG-2 video format you will want to have control over how the file is compressed at the target bitrate of compression in order to achieve the best quality. You would want to duplicate and edit one of the DVD settings in Compressor then set the video bitrate to about 7.5/mbps because anything over that bitrate may cause playback errors on certain DVD players. I may receive compensation from my link. Make sure the audio is set to 192/kbps AC3 in Compressor.
    You can setup distributed processing with Qmaster to enable multiple processor cores in a cluster and take advantage of multi core processing in Compressor. Additional info if necessary (more on the web by searching).
    Then after Compressor is finished compressing the self-contained QT file take the compressed MPEG-2 file and .AC3 audio file and import them into a DVD Studio Pro project and follow these instructions to make the movie autoplay without any menus. I'll throw up some screenshots on the linked page soon to provide a visual reference of how to use DVD Studio Pro to create a DVD that autoplays without a menu.

  • Proper Motion to Final Cut Pro 5 workflow for highest quality in Final Cut.

    I have read several post on Motion 2 to Final Cut Pro. I am somewhat unclear as to how to get the very highest quality Motion 2 project into Final Cut Pro 5. I am currently creating a new DV project in Motion 2, as I am working in DV in Final Cut Pro 5. I notice the Motion 2 files look blurry inside Final Cut Pro 5 when I import the Motion project file and add it to my sequence timeline. Clearly I am doing something wrong. Should I ever export from Motion as a Quicktime movie, and then add that Motion Quicktime movie to the sequence timeline? I know that the Animation codec gives the highest quality from Motion, but what about when you are using the Motion project file in Final Cut Pro 5?
    As always thanks in advance for taking the time to read and reply to my Post,
    Sebastian

    if you're exporting using the DV codec, Quicktime displays the clip at a lesser resolution than the clip actually is, and it will appear blurry on a computer monitor.
    open the clip in QT, go to "Window>Show movie properties". select the video track in the top portion of that window, then the "Visual Settings" tab. Check off the "High Quality" checkbox at the lower right of the window.
    this only affects DV codec clips, from what i understand.
    -bt

  • I have just finished editing a feature length documentary for theatrical  release. How should I output it for the highest quality finished product?

    I have just finished editing a feature length documentary for theatrical  release. How should I output it for the highest quality finished product?

    You may find this article. interesting.
    Good luck,
    Russ

  • HD output process for best / highest quality?

    We shot our film in DVCPRO HD 720p 24.
    We are done editing and ready to output to DVD for festival submission. What is the best way to output the film for the best / highest quality?
    Should we run this through compressor?
    Your help is greatly appreciated.
    Paul

    David, Do you need to adjust the compressor preset to maintain 24p thru dvd authoring (for better quality at lower bitrate - not to mention that full 24p experience on a properly configured dvd player and plasma screen)?
    I know that DVDSP does not register the m2v file as 24p (even though it is). I use bitvice to do my high quality compression so I'm not sure about compressor.

  • Burning the highest quality in idvd 9

    Hi,
    When burning a disk at the highest quality available in idvd 9, what is the final output resolution? I'd like to get as close to 1080i as possible (knowing that I cannot burn HD without a HD burner and equivalent software). I am curious as to what idvd does to your video and stills. I've been creating HD movies in FCE (1280x720) and using idvd to create slideshows and then burning the project to dvd for playback on my HDTV. My images are HD 1280x720 tifs which I have been importing into idvd for a slideshow. On the final output I notice the images look soft, so was wondering what quality idvd is capable of.

    As stated above already iDvd is limited to standard definition. There are no workarounds that I am aware of within iDvd itself. You'll have to think outside of this app if your intention is to go high def and blu-ray or even high def on a standard dvd-r. Forget about playing it back on most macs since apple doesn't currently support Blu-ray playback through its own dvd player app. Your hands are tied unless you choose a third party or an alternate dvd player application to open the file. For example, Roxio's Toast Video Player can do this.
    click here
    Hope this helps but if not just come on back.
    Disclaimer: Apple does not necessarily endorse any suggestions, solutions, or third-party software / products that may be mentioned in this topic. Apple encourages you to first seek a solution at Apple Support. The following links are provided as is, with no guarantee of the effectiveness or reliability of the information. Apple does not guarantee that these links will be maintained or functional at any given time. Use the information above at your own discretion.

  • Highest quality export

    whats the highest quality export for dvd. I have a client who wants to watch it on computer, tv and projection with best quality.
    Also, is a video_TS file better quality than a fcp quicktime mov file?

    To get the highest quality export for DVD, you will need to buy Compressor 4 and create your own preset -- you will need to calculate the max bps based on the amount of video and the size of the DVD (SL vs DL).
    Video_TS isn't a file, it is a folder and part of the structure of the DVD. DVDs use mpeg2, which is highly compressed and there will be a maximum level of quality you can get based on the length of the video.
    A quicktime mov file by itself can contain most any codec, and thus any level of quality. But generally speaking, it is meant for viewing on computers, unless you have a streaming solution with something to decode it for the TV.
    If your original source is HD, you could consider outputting to blu-ray.

  • Small frame rate variation between Motion output and reference video

    Hello all,
    Here's really wonky sort of question for all you Motion/post-production wizzes out there.
    I have a 1920x1080 lower thirds project that I am trying to synch up to a HD up-res of the same dimensions. The problem is that the up-res has a frame rate of 23.976 and Motion only allows for a frame rate of 23.98, so the output synchs up ok at the begining of each act (I have the projects split up into acts), but the further down the time line you go, the more it drifts.
    I've done the math and, for this particular project, the last title begins to appear at 00:20:09:11 in Motion, but appears in FCP at 00:20:09:07, a drift of 4 frames, 3 short of the 7 frames it is supposed to drift if you multiply the timecode in secconds by 23.976 and 23.98, but none the less, very annoying.
    Is there anything that can be done to remedy the situation besides going back after the final Motion output and resynching manually? A three or four frame drift isn't a huge deal, but the largest act I have is 32 minutes, which sounds like a 6 or 7 frame drift. Again not really a huge deal, but I do have several lower thirds that need to be frame accurate (and really, it would be nice if they were all that way).
    Thanks ahead of time.
    -G
    1.6 GHz G5 1.5GB RAM   Mac OS X (10.4.3)   Final Cut Studio

    Yeah. It kind of stinks when you have to swap platforms just to finish a project. AE is also a pain for longform, so I don't want to mislead you.
    I would imagine that Motion would be fine as long as you break the Project up in sections. My workflow is usually like this:
    Generate a matte or slug in a layer above the footage to fill the area where I need the Super or Composite. This should be fairly short (below 1 minute if possible) I may also have to RAZOR out the footage below the matte to match the matte timing. Select the Matte and footage below it if you wish to see the footage and sound in Motion.
    Select File/Send to/ Motion Project
    Create a new Motion Project. Name it for the section I'm editing.
    Add overlays and animations, filters, etc.
    Save project
    switch back to FCP and view/render from FCP.
    then move on to next section of timeline that needs overlays, repeat the procedure. Just copy paste the layers from one Motion project to another if you want to maintain certain layer continuity.
    This way, the Motion projects are managable size and you don't have to re-render the whole FCP project at once. The clips are not long enough for sync issues to appear. And Motion performs much better when the footage is short enough to load into RAM (sub 20seconds for most people).
    Also, to get the most out of Motion, you might want to turn off one of your monitors if you use 2 of them. Motion can use far more VRAM from your graphics card if only one monitor is active.

  • Highest quality slideshow saved to movie file is has terrible resolution in PE12, but PDFs look great. What's up?

    I've saved a PE12 slideshow as the highest quality available, but the resolution is low when viewing. When saved as a PDF the resolution is outstanding. Does anyone know how I can get better resolution from the movie file?
    Message was edited by: Robert Neitz

    How are you creating the video file? PSE itself can only record in the horrid outdated VCD format. Output your slideshow to a WMV file and then use PRE, if you have that, or whatever burning software you have to finalize the video.

  • Highest Quality

    Hi guys,
    I have a Sony camera HDR-SR11 and I am shooting on 1920x1080i 60fps at 16Mbps (highest possible quality on that camera).
    How can I keep the highest quality through the whole process of importing/editing/re-compressing?
    I see my videos are already being imported at 1080p 30fps... Is this good? Can I import at 1080i 60fps? Is this better?
    To re-compress, should I use the iMovie hidef export or export via QT? Which one is better? Should choose 16Mbps when exporting? Any benefit going higher?
    Thanx

    Your camera shoots MPEG-4 AVC/H.264. Open up one of those files in QT and see what the frame rate says (command-i)
    iMovie will convert to what it wants/needs on import
    I would shoot video in every format you camera shoots export that footage how you think you are going to be using then, use the one you want that looks best to you. Depending on what you are outputting to as you final destination each type format has an advantages.
    Even though my camera will shoot 1080/60i, 1080/30p, 1080/24p, 720/60p, 720/30p, and 720/24p I shoot 720p30 because the files are smaller easier to work with, exports well to the web, and meets my needs. Also while you can certainly tell the difference between 1080 and 720 I had an old DV 480i camera that shot better footage than one of my cheap 720p cameras and certainly better than ANY 720p phone My point is size and rate is not everything. There are also people out there that will not shoot at ANY rate but 24. Why? Because they like that "film" look. Something iMovie now supports BTW.
    Not sure what you are talking about on "Final Compression" in iMovie you can share out; small medium, large, 720 or 1080 unless you run a custom export.

  • Highest quality intro video after effects

    i am puzzling to get the highest quality out of my after effects video as a full screen intro for my webpage
    but what i ask is , what format ? wich Steps ? and what's most compatible?
    yvesm

    highest quality
    That is an indefinite variable. You can do the best quality output but it may not be functional for your website as bandwidth is a concern and you dont want it to struggle to buffer.
    For HTML5 video types that are compatible for various devices regardless of it supporting Flash or not, you need to supply at least 3 formats: .mp4, .ogv, .webm. Read here why: http://caniuse.com/video
    Another alternative is to upload your video to Youtube and embed a video from there to your webpage. You just need to upload 1 file. Youtube will take care of conversion, optimization, load balancing, etc... And will play HTML5 wherever possible and will fall back to a flash player where HTML5 is not possible.

  • Export setting in highest quality

    Dear all, I am new in PE11 and I am looking for the best export setting in order to keep a clean and highest quality possible version of my movie. From that clean copy I will be able to create different versions (for youtube, DVD, PC, etc...). Any idea? Thanks for your help.

    Welcome to the forum.
    Will you be re-editing this material at any time? That can make a difference.
    If so, I like outputting to a lossless CODEC, like Lagarith, or UT Lossless - both free. See this article: http://forums.adobe.com/message/4556586#4556586
    The one drawback to such an intermediate is that the resulting file will have limited use, directly. It can be shared with others, for computer playback, but the recipient must have the same CODEC on their computer. For YouTube, Vimeo, DVD, etc., the lossless file will need to be Imported into a New Project, where it can be re-edited, but primarily to be output again, as is required for the intended delivery medium, i.e. YouTube, Vimeo, DVD-Video, etc.
    For some general guidelines, see this article. Though written for PrPro, it covers all the high points for PrE: http://forums.adobe.com/thread/878590?tstart=0
    Good luck,
    Hunt

  • Printing to DVD at the highest quality possible

    Hello out there. I have a question. I'm currently editing a project that was shot on 35mm film telecined full frame (4:3) to DigiBeta and down converted to DVCAM. Durning post we added a 1.85 matte (as he footage was originally composed for 1.85). My main concern is to output this footage at the highest quality possible. (Is FCP's Compression a good tool for this) Also I was wondering if anyone had a link to a discussion where I could find out how to burn a dvd with no menu that continuously loops. I'm currently using the FCP Production Suite with DVD S Studio Pro 4. Thanks
    Erv

    If you do a search you can find discussions on both of these topics as they have been discussed over and over, especially the compression one.
    this is a good read:
    http://www.kenstone.net/fcphomepage/first_playwarmouth.html

Maybe you are looking for