COMPRESSOR COMPRESSION CHOICE

Finalizing a low-budg film. Got about a 100 minutes of 10 bit uncompressed vid divided into 5 reels. Color corrected in FCP5 using Magic Bullet and exported 10bit, each Reel approx. 20 minutes/35 gigs each. About to deartifact, deinterlace in AE6 w/Magic Bullet then export again. I think I then end up RGB color space, but whatever.
Question 1. Should I export out of AE6/MB 10 bit uncompressed for Compressor? (YUV or RGB if I have the choice)
Question 2. What compress rate is the best in Compressor for each reel? I plan to import each Compressor compressed reel (combining the 5 reels) into DVD Pro to burn a 4.5 DVD of the whole thing. Each Reel needs to be compressed to about 1 gig each for it to fit in other words.
I thought about compressing the whole thing, but figure the computer would be down for a couple, three days and 1 glitch and the whole thing has to be started again.
I'd like to do a dual layer, but consumer external brands like La Cie seem not to work well with DVD pro. This is not a master. Just a sales tool at this point. But the time it takes to do this is painful and want to end up with the best product possible.
Any advice will be helpful.
G5 2.5   Mac OS X (10.4.6)   FCP5, AE6, DVDPro, Magic Bullet

Hey Bad Baby Post,
if i had a choice between YUV vs. RGB, i would go totally YUV 10-bit, not 12 or 16-bit, since the file sizes would be HUGE!
if you wanted a DVD-5, then your compressed 100 minutes of video with Dolby *.ac3 audio (stereo) then you would be lookign at a bit-rate of about 5.8 mbps average, maximum of 7 mbps and minimum of 3.5 mbps. of course this is assuming that it only has 100 minutes of the feature, and NO OTHER VIDEO. if it had menus, then a few static (still menus would be cool).
if you would go with a DVD-9, then with the same 100 minutes of video, you can have a CBR of 8 mbps with Dolby *.ac3 Stereo (@ 192 kbps).
also, keep in mind, for the DVD-9's, the burners are just fine, you can get an internal Pioneer DVR-11D that is AWESOME, but you would have to download Batchburn to make the OS see the drive as a super drive (like this, you can burn from iDVD, DVD SP, iTunes, etc). if not, you can just use a third party disc burner like Roxio's Toast Titanium (i use this all the time) or Dragon Burn (another i use all the time). where you might have problems is not the nurning liek i said, but the actual playback. remember, the majority of DVD DL discs are +R, not -R. some older players have trouble playing such discs. DVD-roms' (like in a lot of compters) have no trouble with this media.
i would go with a DVD-5, just for maximum compatibility with the DVD ste top players out there.
Mikey M.

Similar Messages

  • Premiere pro cs3, limited compression choices.

    Premiere pro cs3,  windows 7
    I'm trying to export my movies,but no matter what video choice I use, the program will only  compress in millions of colors, which makes videos that are way too big to use.  How do I get the other compression choices to appear?

    Depends on the final destination: dvd, web or ...?
    Format and bitrate  determinens the filesize.

  • Compressor Compression Question

    I have a huge QuickTime file that I output out of FCP 7, that is a 40 minute long presentation that mixes live video with Power Point slides. The video was shot using a Sony HXR-NX5U and the timeline used the ProRes422 codec. The final size of the movie out of FCP is 66.91 gigs, which I want to compress down to 2 gigs or less to post on YouTube.
    What settings might I use in Compressor to achieve this? I'm looking to compress it as a QuickTime H.264 file.
    Thank you!

    I'm running Final Cut Studio 3, with FCP 7. I know of the YouTube preset in Compressor, but will it automatically compress down to the size I need, or do I need to limit the data rate, or adjust any other settings?

  • CAN COMPRESSOR COMPRESS TO A WMV (Windows media player file?)

    Hi,
    Just curious if Compressor or better yet for what I am doing final cut can compress to a wmv (windows media format)? for the sake of downloading of our website.
    thank you

    Actually once you install Flip4Mac it works within compressor too. Just select quicktime export components when creating a new compression proifile and you will see all the WMV options.

  • DVDSP vs Compressor compression

    Is it better to compress my video with Compressor or use my raw uncompressed Quicktime movies as assets in DVDSP and have it do the compression when building a disc?
    A co-worker says DVDSP is better since it automatically adjusts quality to make assets fit within a disc. Compressor has presets, but requires tweaking if my program length doesn't comform to one of the MPEG 2 time presets (90, 120, etc minutes)

    The general rule is that Compressor will give you complete control over your encoding process. Working in DVDSP with your assets encoded, will give you faster builds too.
    An important advantage of using Compressor is its capabilities to encode your audio to Dolby 2.0 (AC3) what will give you more space for your video (letting use a higher bitrate to your video). DVDSP will not compress your audio, leaving it as AIFF/PCM what most probably will give you some high bitrates issues during encoding/playback (specially in stand alone player).
    is better since it automatically adjusts quality to make assets fit within a disc
    I never encode in DVDSP and never heard about any automatic fit feature. You must change the encoding settings inside DVDSP preferences to fit your assets (remember you'll not be able to encode your audio to Dolby inside DVDSP).
    But anyone with more experience in inside encoding will tell us if that automatic feature really exists !
    Hope it helps !
      Alberto

  • HD best compression choice?

    Greetings,
    I am working on a project in which all the source material is derived from a Digital SLR, being used to shoot "time lapse". It works pretty good, and the images are 3000x2000, which I can easily make into a movie using After Effects. I first began scaling the images to 1280x720 at 30fps, and would output this to DVC PRO HD 720p. (Another great thing is that you can introduce camera moves using AE at this step). Anyhow, I have lately been exploring the 1920x1080 format. When you use the template in AE, it specifies a frame rate of 24fps, which is really no problem for me, but it begs the question, given the nature of the source material, if that is the best frame rate for me? And what is the difference between DVCPRO HD 1080i60 vs DVDPRO HD 1080i50? Is this even the prefered output format for me ? Difficult to find information on these formats, and the manuals are no help. I have yet to upgrade to FCP6, but I understand there is a NEW HD compression scheme. So I guess, this is a general compression question, but would love to get any feedback from users on this one.
    Thank,
    Dave Berry

    given the nature of the source material, if that is the best frame rate for me?
    Well, this begs the question, what will you be delivering? 23.98 is a good frame rate, if your photos progressed at that speed. 29.97 is good if they progressed at that speed. What are you delivering? Format? To whom?
    And what is the difference between DVCPRO HD 1080i60 vs DVDPRO HD 1080i50?
    1080i60 is an NTSC frame rate...59.94fps...based on the 29.97 (30fps) NTSC standard. 1080i50 is a PAL HD rate, based on the 25fps PAL standard.
    Is this even the prefered output format for me ?
    Again...what format do you want to deliver? DVCPRO HD tape? HDCAM? DVD? Film out? This determines EVERYTHING.
    I have yet to upgrade to FCP6, but I understand there is a NEW HD compression scheme.
    Yes, ProRes 422. Uncompressed HD quality at 1/4 the drive space requirements. Many options available there.
    Shane

  • What is the best compression choice for importing audio?

    Hi
    What is the best setting for importing audio into itunes?
    thnx

    There is no "best", it depends on what is important to you.
    If you want the same fidelity as the CD use AIFF, but this will result in very large files and reduce the number of songs you can put on your iPod.
    If you want more songs on your iPod use 128 AAC. I wouldn't go any smaller for music.
    If you want a compromise try Apple Lossless. Keep in mind if you have a Shuffle that Apple Lossless files won't work on that device.

  • DV 24p to DVD - Best compression and workflow

    Hello,
    I shot my thesis film on the Panasonic DVX-100a a few years back. Ran out of money and never finished. Luckily, I have the resources to now wrap it up and have some questions about the final export to DVD workflow.
    We re-digitized the film from the original tapes and rebuilt it in FCP. Cut it, had it mixed, and now ready to output it.
    What I've done thus far:
    1. Exported Quicktime movie from timeline (using project settings - DV)
    2. Opened that up with compressor, compressed to 90 min best quality
    3. Screened on plasma (looked like ***) and LCD computer monitor (looked ok)
    What I'd like to know:
    1. Is there a preferred workflow/setting to go out of FCP and onto DVD that will yield better results than what the steps I described above?
    What I was considering doing:
    1. Exporting an uncompressed or animation version from the timeline.
    2. Opening that in Compressor, bumping up the bit rate to 6, using CBR.
    3. Making beta dub to screen for interested parties.
    Original Footage:
    1. We shot Panasonic DVX-100a 24p. Super happy with the look of the film until I saw it on the plasma. I love that rough look but not when it looks like an accident.
    So, any thoughts or recommendations would be greatly appreciated. Thanks for taking the time to read this and potentially help my little movie.
    Best,
    Wolf

    Not really; DVDs just aren't good enough for huge, progressive plasma TVs. You can certainly do a lot by keeping the bitrate high enough (but not high enough to cause problems), using a tripod, good lighting, good camera, and best settings. But it still is an interlaced, standard definition source. And of course, don't transcode to a different format when you don't have to; go from your source format to mpeg2.

  • Which Compression has the most bang for the buck?

    When I'm 'exporting' a quicktime that I need to post for download, I try to get the size of the file down as much as I can while preserving the video quality.
    However, there are so many compression choices, and then more choices with that! Which is best? Sorenson? Motion J-peg?

    However, there are so many compression choices, and then more choices with that! Which is best? Sorenson?I agree with David here. H.264/AAC generally provides the best quality for a given file size but does require a QT 7 (or eqivalent) media player. Sorenson 3/AAC would maximize compatibility with older, less powerful platforms but requires larger files for a given level of quality. The MPEG4/AAC combination is somewhere in the middle offering rigid standards with easy to use preset management. Would recommend DivX/XviD only if you are trying to attract Windows users and don't care about the possibly of alienating mainstream Mac users.

  • What is the best lossless compression for video?

    I have a large amount of captured video, which is saved in uncompressed format.
    I want to archive this video and I need to figure out what the best compression choice is.
    It's video only and I want the archived materials to be compressed as losslessly as possible and as small as possible. Losslessness is more important than size. The original material was captured in FCP from a video camera using Firewire. It is NTCS DV.
    Multiple angles of this source material were edited in FCP and rendered to make the final, uncompressed files. Those are what I need to compress and archive.
    Any suggestions would be appreciated.

    There is no such thing as lossless compression.
    This is not really true. There are many ways to compress - just google "compression algorithms" and you'll find some. Two basic schemes are either lossless or lossy. Lossless seeks to remove redundant or repetitive information, this is like Run Length Encoding or LZW encoding. Lossy throws away information that is generally "not perceived". JPEG, MPEG, H.264, DV are examples of lossy compression.
    YUV "lossless" is 4:2:2 and is considered uncompressed, yet it takes up less space than RGB 4:4:4 encoding. Simply zipping the file compresses it (uncompressed codecs squeeze better, but DV does compress, indicating redundant information) - a TIFF sequence might have run length encoding or LZW. Both are lossless.
    To get back to the question, Patrick:Losslessness is more important than size.
    H.264 is a fantastic compression - it is, however, FAR from lossless AND it is not directly editable. You'd need to convert it back to an editable format, ensuring even more loss. Not within the parameters of your desired solution...
    Patrick

  • Lowest compression QT.dv or QT.mov?

    This has probably been asked a million times but -
    Which loses most QT.dv or QT.mov?
    ie. what are the comparative compression rates?
    And, which is best to export to iMovie HD6 dv for best results?

    If DV uses a specific compression - what is it?
    1) DV and DVCPRO25 usually have a video data compression rate on the order of 25.0-29.0 Mbps while DVCPRO50 is usually on the order of 55.0-59.0 Mbps and HDV (sometimes referred to as DV/DVCPRO100 by some) can have an "actual" video data rate between 80 and 120 Mbps.
    2) The DV export option creates a file with both DV video and DV audio content. Thus, the DV, DVCPRO, and DVCPRO50 data rate stated above must be doubled to give the "total" data rate for a DV stream file which determines the "total" file size. On the other hand, the MOV file container contains a DV video track and an audio track of your choice (e.g., Uncompressed/Linear PCM, IMA 4:1, MPEG-4 AAC, AMR Narrow, MPEG Layer 2, MPEG Layer 3, A-Law 2:1, Apple Lossless, Mace 3:1, Mace 6:1, QDesign Music 2, Qualcomm PureVoice, µ-Law 2:1, and various integer/Floating Point compression schemes) which can have widely varying audio data rates/settings.
    3) Thus, by varying the DV stream and the MOV compression choices/combinations, I can make either the DV or MOV file appear to have a higher or lower (i.e., total) compression rate than the other. That is why I asked how you are making your comparisons and which specific codecs were being used.

  • PremierePro4 Help with Capture Video Compression Options

    Last week I started converting my old VHS tapes using a Canopus ADVC 110 box, a Mac with OSX 10.4.11, and PremierePro 4.0.0.
    Everything went fine until last night when I lost my compression choices in Premiere - Capture Settings - Video - Compression.
    Previously I had numerous compression type options and was using either DVCPro or DVCPro50. There were also many others available.
    Now, I only see DVCPro50 when my Canopus is attached as the source. If I remove the Canopus my iSight becomes the source and its only compression type is Y'CbCr 4:2:2 - uyvy.
    Thus far, I restarted and replugged everything, verified permissions, and unloaded and reloaded Premiere. None of that works.
    I suspect there is something running interference somewhere that I need to delete or reset.
    Help is greatly welcomed. Thanks

    I am also not sure how Mac OS updates affect other things, but on the PC, they can kill a video driver, or an audio driver instantly, and often do. However, those PC-specific behaviors should have zero impact on your options drop-downs going missing. I was just thinking aloud there.
    I'm trying to think of what else might have changed, as when something works one day, but not the next, then something has changed, and the task is to find out what it was.
    I know that iTunes usually also updates QT, and that is why I do not allow it to update, until I am positive that the PC version of QT is a good one with Adobe products - not all have been, so I am skitterish.
    On the PC, QT loves to install and go and seize the file associations of everything that it can play, unless one does a manual install. I wonder if QT Player was also installed with your iTunes? Also not sure how a Mac does the file type association linking, but on the PC, if certain programs loose their file associations, then strange things can happen. I assume that you are doing your Capture to MOV (you probably said in the OP, but I've forgotten), so I wonder if QT has messed with the file type. Wish I could tell you where to even start, but I cannot. No one ever lets me near their Mac's, as all PC-users are bad joux-joux!
    Just thinking aloud again, but good luck,
    Hunt

  • Compressor 4 command line -in and -out points

    I'm trying to use Compressor 4.1 command line interface to compress various video clips. While I can compress an entire file, start to end, without issue, I can't figure out how to compress a subset of the source file by setting in and out points. The -help information states I can set -in <hh:mm:ss;ff> and -out <hh:mm:ss;ff> parameters except they seem to have no effect as Compressor compresses the full file. Has anyone been able to specify -in and -out parameters successfully? If so, can you please share the appropriate syntax?
    FWIW: here is the sytax for command that I've been using to compress 2 seconds of source video:
    /applications/Compressor.app/Contents/MacOS/compressor -batchname sampleBatch  -jobpath /Shows/filename_HD.mov -settingpath /Settings/480pProxy.cmprstng  -locationpath /Clips/clipName_HD.mov -in 00:00:04;00  -out 00:00:06;00
    OSX 10.9.2, Compressor 4.1 and Compressor 4.1.1

    You have to use quotation marks around the in an out points because of the semi colon.
    /Applications/Compressor.app/Contents/MacOS/Compressor -batchname "In and Out Example"  -jobpath /Shows/filename_HD.mov -settingpath /Settings/480pProxy.cmprstng  -locationpath /Clips/clipName_HD.mov -in "00:00:04;00"  -out "00:00:06;00"

  • Compressing a 150 min. project with lots f movement

    I've got the new updated FCP 2 on a Mac G5. I have been trying - for the last 2 days- to make a DVD in DVD studio Pro using compressor. When I use the Compressor DVD 2.37 settings and import to DVD studio Pro it says the media doesn't match. Says the same thing when I use the Program settings from compressor.
    Also, sometines when Compressor compresses and it says, do you want to save? The compressor is STILL saving 5 hours later.
    What am I dointg wrong? I have to get this to compress and burn now for a client!

    Scott
    No magic. To fit such lenght in a single DVD5 you'll loose your quality.
    freezes during others and other times the timecode jumps.
    Those playback errors are not related with encoding bitrate. Are you using good quality media? How did you burn your disc: DVDSP, Toast? What burning speed you use? Did you use AC3 audio, right?
    Hope that helps !
      Alberto

  • Compressing long format video

    HELLO everyone. I have a live event that I recorded and is approximately 90 minutes in length. I'm not sure the proper way to compress this video so that it fits on one DVD. Really, quick I'm exporting this video via FCP using QUICKTIME MOVIE. My settings I believe are ok. I have:
    1. DV NTSC 48KHZ
    2. INCLUDE = AUDIO AND VIDEO
    3. MARKERS = NONE
    Now, I was wondering if splittling the video in half and make two DVD's is the way to go or is there another way to compress it? I really don't have any experience in compressing files especially long format files. Thanks for your help.
    ERV

    Hey Dave, I just exported another Q.T. file using the same settings now my quicktime file is 9 gigs instead of 18 because I cut the video in half. If the video is 9 gigs when I import it into DVD STUDIO PRO and DVD SP begins to compress it will it still be 9 gigs once DVD SP compressor compresses it or will it be fewer gigs. The reason I'm asking is because I spent all night trying to compress 90 minutes of footage it took 12 hours and still wasn't complete. The Q.T. file was still 18 gigs when I tryed to burn it to DVD and as a result could not fit on a 4.7 gigs dvd. I know you mentioned compressor as a way to burn my footage on but I'm so illiterate on that program is there and easy approach to accomplishing this task using that program?

Maybe you are looking for