Is iTunes "Sound Check" better than five years ago?

I got into iTunes (briefly) about five years ago.  I got all excited about mixed playlists and what-all ... but I burned out quickly because the Sound Check feature that would regulate the volumes from different CDs was mostly worthless.  Most songs averaged out, but that one track in ten would still sneak in there, too loud or too soft, and ruin the listening vibe in the house.
I ditched iTunes and went back to my CD player.
Now I'd like to get back into iTunes again and I'm wondering if Sound Check ever had any significant improvements in the last five years?  Did Apple finally perfect it?
Do we finally have mix playlists that play consistently, like one properly re-mastered compilation CD?  Or are occasional tracks still showing up too loud or too soft?
-John

John_Neumann wrote:
Thanks for the replies, Wolf and Sanjampet.
Yep, both of you are spot on correct about some of the dynamics that affect Sound Check.  The only thing I know is that, five years ago, I didn't like it.  I also remember not really being able to make manual adjustments work for me because I have music playing constantly and jumping up and running over to the Mac while an offending song is on my mind got mighty inconvenient.  That's why I stuck with my CD player. ...
I think you answered my question for me.  No, Sound Check is no different than it was five years ago. 
Not quite what I said.  I certainly expect it has improved over 5 years, I can only tell you it will never be perfect.  And that is relevant because of your expectations.
The fact is, CD players do not have SoundCheck at all.  But when your CD mismatches song volumes, that does not "offend your ears".  And yet, oddly, iTunes does.  Listening sequentially to a CD you already know, you are accustomed to those particular mismatches, so they "sound right" to you.  What I'm speaking of here is cognitive bias, which is human and normal, and the thing to do is simply be aware it's there.
I too have tried playlists and was not impressed.  I remember when the level adjustment (in Song Properties) came out and thought "about time".  And I've never spent the time to actually try playlists again.  But I did not abandon iTunes entirely simply because one of its features "is not for me", i.e. sucked.  Digital playback is still the Best Jukebox Ever, with instant and searchable access to my music.  CDs are in every way inferior.* 
It sounds like you jumped into digital playback with both feet, found some of its features were not ready for prime time, and jumped back out.  I would suggest easing back in with one foot, remembering that setup is a one-time task and it's pure profit from there. 
* purposefully ignoring the question of musical fidelity, some believe compression is bad, others believe digital is bad.  Not this thread.

Similar Messages

  • Balancing volume/gain across clips - anything like iTunes Sound Check

    I am now in charge of a pretty large pile of pre-cut FCP clips captured in less than ideal circumstances, but with reasonably clear narrated voice overs. There are hundreds of short similar clips, but the volume varies tremendously, and I am trying to assemble them into longer sequences.
    So - since they are all speech at a similar volume, is there any batch operation I can run on my clips to raise or lower the gain on each one to the same final level? I am looking for something similar to iTunes' sound check.

    You could TRY (try) the normalize feature by sending it to Soundtrack after you edit.
    Might work ok for you.
    CaptM

  • How do i deauthorize one computer in itunes when the limit of 5 authorizations was reached less than one year ago?

    How do I deauthorize just one PC in itunes when the limit of 5 authorizations was met less than one year ago?

    the authorized 5 are one computer

  • How to search event more than 1 year ago in Iphone calendar?

    Everytime I forgot events in the past, let say more than 1 year ago, I always search in calendar outlook. But I cannot find it in Iphone. Anyone know how to solve this?
    Thanks.

    I just tested mine, and you are right. While I generally only sync and have the restriction in iTunes set for calendar not to sync more than 30 days, I found a recurring birthday event and it would only return the event in search to 2009. I never knew that. I guess we could provide feedback to Apple at http://www.apple.com/feeback/iphone.html

  • Itunes  + Satellite tv from europe 1 year ago requested = solved by

    Yes I asked Apple more than a year ago to provide me with IP TV that Apple / some company buy's from the European channel listing from the satelite providers and stream it via the internet to me and I can pay via Itunes.
    768 channels from across the world for $70 yeah baby no more propaganda.
    Sorry NOT FOR OSX , WINSLOW'S ONLY.
    Seeing that the national TV service is so poor in ******* some guy managed to do it.
    http://www.satellite-pc.com/video/

    Running the script by python2 solves it for me:
    su - mythtv -c "nice -n 19 python2 /usr/bin/tv_grab_nl_py --output ~/listings.xml"
    Best regards,
    Cedric

  • I purchased CS6 less than a year ago; my serial number is known, but i can't use it anymore?

    I purchased CS6 less than a year ago; my serial number is known, but i get the message that my trial period has ended and i cannot use the products anymore... what to do now?

    Hello Sarika,
    I tried to do as suggested in your link, but I can’t open the programs anymore, so I can’t get to the possibility of deactivate!
    I did get the updates, but that’s all…
    Any other way of getting there?
    thank you for trying to help,
    Angeline
    [email protected]
    Op 16 apr. 2014, om 00:02 heeft sarika02 <[email protected]> het volgende geschreven:
    Re: I purchased CS6 less than a year ago; my serial number is known, but i can't use it anymore?
    created by sarika02 in Creative Suites - View the full discussion
    Hi tomaatje,
    Try the steps suggested in given link:- http://helpx.adobe.com/creative-suite/kb/trial--1-launch.html
    Do let us know if it helps.
    Sarika
    Please note that the Adobe Forums do not accept email attachments. If you want to embed a screen image in your message please visit the thread in the forum to embed the image at http://forums.adobe.com/message/6301871#6301871
    Replies to this message go to everyone subscribed to this thread, not directly to the person who posted the message. To post a reply, either reply to this email or visit the message page: http://forums.adobe.com/message/6301871#6301871
    To unsubscribe from this thread, please visit the message page at http://forums.adobe.com/message/6301871#6301871. In the Actions box on the right, click the Stop Email Notifications link.
    Start a new discussion in Creative Suites at Adobe Community
    For more information about maintaining your forum email notifications please go to http://forums.adobe.com/thread/416458?tstart=0.

  • When I OCR two versions of the same document and then compare th documents in Acrobat Pro XI, I usually get the message that there are no changes to mark.  However, I know there a quite a few number of changes.  I raised this question more than a year ago

    When I OCR two versions of the same document and then compare the documents in Acrobat Pro XI, I usually get the message that there are no changes to mark.  However, I know there a quite a few number of changes.  I raised this question more than a year ago, and the response I received had to do with the quality of the OCR and the scans of the documents.  However, if I use Acrobat Pro XI to save the same documents in Word and then run a comparison in Word all of the changes are marked.  When a PDF is saved as a Word document in Acrobat Pro XI, is a different OCR module being used than the one used in Acrobat Pro XI for text recognition?

    OCR is only for recoginition of the image / picture of text provided by an scanner.
    Content typed into a Word file which is converted to a PDF is (in Word and in PDF) *not* an image  or picture of text - it is the digital text. So, no OCR involved.
    When the "digital" (renderable) text of a PDF's page content is exported to Word no OCR is involved.
    When a PDF's content is from the image output of a scanner and this is a picture of text then OCR comes into play.
    If this content is exported to Word before doing OCR then it is the image that is exported to the Word file.
    Once OCR is performed it is the OCR output that is exported.
    OCR output is (always will be) impacted by "the quality of the OCR and the scans of the documents". 
    Regardless "Compare" is based on a Word file output to PDF1 then edits to the Word file followed by an output to PDF2. You use Acrobat Pro to do a compare of PDF1 & PDF2.
    Paper 1 scanned to image 1 to image 1 in PDF1 that gets OCR 1 and
    Paper 2 scanned to image 2 to image 2 in PDF2 that gets OCR 2
    being processed with Acrobat Pro's Compare can certainly be done.
    But - well you've described what can be observed.
    Be well...

  • HT4061 Device had been purchased in Hong Kong less than one year ago. May I get warranty service in London?

    Device had been purchased in Hong Kong less than one year ago. May I get warranty service in London? Actually i have problem of "Error 23" and didn't succeed to solve it.

    Warranty and support for the iPhone are provided only in the country in which the iPhone was officially sold. To get service for an iPhone purchased in Hong Kong, you'll have to take the iPhone back to HK or send it to someone you know there who can get it serviced and then ship it back to you.
    Regards.

  • I got my ipod 5 less than a year ago, and yesterday the speakers stopped working. Will I get a new ipod for free?

    Yesterday, i plugged in headphones, and when i took them out, it said headphones were still in it when i tried to change the volume. Now it cannot play any volume, or take in any volume, unless you have headphones plugged in and the have a built in microphone. Since i got my ipod less than a year ago, will i get a new one for free?

    First
    - Try cleaning out/blowing out the headphone jack. Try inserting/removing the plug a dozen times or so. There is a little switch in the headphone jack that disconnects the speaker when the headphone jack is inserted.

  • Five years ago our family purchased at Costco this Bravia TV (KDL46EX621) and a Blue Ray player. Whi

    Five years ago our family purchased at Costco this Bravia TV (KDL46EX621) and a Blue Ray player. While we had less expensive options, we decided to go with Sony because of the quality it represents. We are light TV users, don't even have cable tv. The TV has remained in the same spot since we have had it. Two years after the purchase, we started having trouble turning on the tv. So we figured out that we could turn it on by unplugging the unit and plugging back on. It was a hassle and disappointing to have to do that with such a reputable brand tv. About three months ago the unplugging and plugging routine did not work so we took it to a repair shop. I just heard back from the repair shop that they cannot fix the tv because the replacement part is not available. The first part that they tried was defective. I've wonder if this is a factory defect. The Repair shop will refund the $285 that I had paid for the repair. Not being able to fix my $1000 tv adds insult to injury. Especially when I call Sony's technical support and their recommendation is that I purchase another tv!!! Wow! That is poor customer service. I can tell you, if I have to purchase a new tv, unless you all can help me with this, it will NOT be a Sony. I'm not one to complain and write negative consumer reports, but in this case I really think it may merrit one. Anyway, today I will take my tv to a Sony authorized repair shop in San Antonio (Consumer Electronics). How can you make up for all the hassle? Even though I realize the unit is no longer under warranty I would appreciate if Sony would follow this case to make sure the tv can get fixed. It would be even nicer if you could cover the repair costs or simply replace my unit to a good working one.  

    Five years ago our family purchased at Costco this Bravia TV (KDL46EX621) and a Blue Ray player. While we had less expensive options, we decided to go with Sony because of the quality it represents. We are light TV users, don't even have cable tv. The TV has remained in the same spot since we have had it. Two years after the purchase, we started having trouble turning on the tv. So we figured out that we could turn it on by unplugging the unit and plugging back on. It was a hassle and disappointing to have to do that with such a reputable brand tv. About three months ago the unplugging and plugging routine did not work so we took it to a repair shop. I just heard back from the repair shop that they cannot fix the tv because the replacement part is not available. The first part that they tried was defective. I've wonder if this is a factory defect. The Repair shop will refund the $285 that I had paid for the repair. Not being able to fix my $1000 tv adds insult to injury. Especially when I call Sony's technical support and their recommendation is that I purchase another tv!!! Wow! That is poor customer service. I can tell you, if I have to purchase a new tv, unless you all can help me with this, it will NOT be a Sony. I'm not one to complain and write negative consumer reports, but in this case I really think it may merrit one. Anyway, today I will take my tv to a Sony authorized repair shop in San Antonio (Consumer Electronics). How can you make up for all the hassle? Even though I realize the unit is no longer under warranty I would appreciate if Sony would follow this case to make sure the tv can get fixed. It would be even nicer if you could cover the repair costs or simply replace my unit to a good working one.  

  • I started my iTunes account on my Dell Desktop years ago and want to know how to import my files onto my new MacBook Pro?

    I started my iTunes account on my Dell Desktop years ago and want to know how to import my files onto my new MacBook Pro?

    It should be in Favorites.
    If not, click on the desktop then go to Finder menu > Preferences > Sidebar and tick Music.
    Your Music folder is in Macintosh HD > Users > Your username.

  • Reinstalled iTunes - "Sound Check" option no longer effective

    I've always used and liked the "Sound Check" option in iTunes. Recently, due to 13-year-old hijinx, my library became corrupt. I uninstalled iTunes, downloaded the most recent version, and reinstalled it. I assumed the "Sound Check" option defaulted to "off", so I proceeded to add all my music folders to create a new library in the newly installed iTunes. Then I realized the "Sound Check" option was actually turned on - why I don't know, since I hadn't switched it on. I had assumed after the "add music folders" process I would turn on "Sound Check" and iTunes would read the music files to obtain the volume (usually a several hour process with my 6000+ songs). But it never did read the files. And now, even though "Sound Check" is on, it doesn't seem to me that the songs play at the same level. I've tried switching "Sound Check" off and then turning it on again to no avail. Is there a way to manually force iTunes to re-listen to the music files to re-set the levels for "Sound Check"? -Murray

    hmmmmm. this is going to be experimental. (because i've never seen the problem i'm checking on manifest in quite this way before.) but in theory, it could help identify the cause.
    Sound Check is an itunes preference. sometimes we get cases of preferences refusing to change for folks because one of the itunes preference files has gone skunky in some way. so it's plausible that you've got a preference file gone bad here.
    let's try an experiment aimed at seeing if this might be the cause of the problem in your case.
    quit itunes.
    head into your user accounts control panel and create a new user account with full administrative rights. (there's help documentation on how to do that at the left of the control panel screen.) while you're in that control panel, switch off "fast user switching" in your logging-on preferences.
    now log out of the old account and log into the new account.
    launch itunes.
    import some music into the (currently empty) library in the user account. (perhaps a couple of different albums with fairly wildly different recording levels.) listen to them with Sound Check on, and with Sound Check off.
    does sound check make a difference in the new account?
    (there's a different set of preference files in the new account and the old account, which is why a preference problem in one account usually doesn't affect preferences in a different account, and why this experiment may indicate the preference files are at fault in the old account.)

  • IPod/iTunes Sound Check Sync

    Half the music on my iPod comes from my own computer that originally had Sound Check enabled in my iTunes. But the other half of my iPod music comes from my friends' computers, and I know that not every one of them used Sound Check. So the obvious problem is that the volume levels for the music on my iPod are not all normalized. I know that you can't directly Sound Check songs on the iPod, and that it only happens in iTunes. I also know that the solution is for me to import the iPod music into iTunes (with iPodRip), thus Sound Checking anything that wasn't originally normalized, and then updating it back to my iPod. But I don't want to import my entire iPod library if I don't have to.
    So my question is this: Is there any was to know which of the music on my iPod was originally encoded with Sound Check? I only want to fix what needs fixing.
    Thanks.

    I can't remember the exact phrase as I'm not near a Mac with any sound checked files on it... It is at the bottom of the left column when it's present.
    <TABLE CELLPADDING=0 CELLSPACING=0 WIDTH=100%><TR><TD>It was a joke about life...  
    Dave</TD><TD ALIGN="RIGHT">U</TD></TR></TABLE>

  • ITunes Sound Check

    When Sound Check is enabled in iTunes preferences, does this feature carry over to the iPod on my iPhone 4s when I sync?

    It should if it's checked when syncing

  • I have a refurbished iPhone 5 (which I got less than a year ago) and the screen becomes unresponsive and there is a purplish haze that appears on the phone when I try to use it. Hasn't been dropped or cracked.. What could it be? help!!

    I Have a refurbished iPhone 5 that is less than a year old (apple replaced my first one due to a battery fault) but this one has all of a sudden become unresponsive most times and a purple haze has come thru the background on the lCd. The cursor goes abit cranky sometimes too and jumps from Window to window?! It has never been dropped or screen has never been replaced either no exposure to water or sun. This happened after I upgraded to the new iOS 8.1. I don't think it was the update but I've never had good results from updating the iPhone anyway..
    HELP?? I have an appt with Apple tomorrow but don't know if I can wait that long!!
    THanks in advance.

    Hey jojo-10!
    Here is an article for you that can help you troubleshoot this issue with your iPhone:
    iPhone and iPod touch: Charging the battery
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1476
    Thanks for coming to the Apple Support Communities!
    Regards,
    Braden

Maybe you are looking for