Real Mess with Total Broadband Package installatio...

I ordered BT Total Broadband and Vision package in July 2012, including Home Install for the BT Vision, which I paid for.
The telephone engineer and Vision engineer appointments were arranged to take place on the same day - 20/8/12.
However, BT inexplicably cancelled this date via email, and re-scheduled the installations for 24/8.
Then BT cancelled the telephone engineer's appointment, saying it would not now be necessary as our line had been tested and was working (we were previously with Virgin.)
On 20/8/12 a Vision TV engineer suddenly turned up out of the blue, but obviously could not install the TV service, as our phone & broadband service were not due to go live until 24/8.
BT had apparently not conveyed this change of date to the Vision engineer. I told him of our revised date of 24/8, he said he would 'keep an eye on things' and I therefore assumed he would be returning on the date arranged by BT.
It is now 24/8.
I have installed the broadband myself, which is working fine, as is the wireless connection.
But that's the only thing that has gone smoothly.  I cannot receive any incoming calls at all (I can only make outgoing calls) and two of my three phone sockets have been completely dead since BT took over.
I managed to book a telephone engineer for tomorrow (25/8) to look at the lines; I obviously did need that telephone engineer's appointment after all, then.
And no Vision engineer has turned up to install the TV service as arranged, and as I paid for.
I rang the call centre in India who told me there was no record of a Vision Home Install appointment and that i would need to do this myself! I replied that I had booked one, it had been confirmed and I had even paid for it.
They then put me through to a person who I can only describe as a cocky 'gentleman' apparently in the UK with quite an attitude (I asked for his name and he gave a first name which I won't mention here) who apparently books engineers.
He told me that as my timeslot had now been missed and they had no way of knowing which the engineer had been assigned (and the engineer had not contacted me to let me know there was a problem) he could not give the engineer a b*****king and said in not so many words that it was basically my tough luck the engineer hadn't showed and I now would have to wait another week until 31/8/12 for the next available appointment to have my Vision service installed.
I have worked in CS and had I ever used such language to a customer (even in a non-confrontational way) I would have been fired on the spot.
This 'gentleman' refused give out the phone no. of engineers so that I could contact them direct.
I pointed out that I had taken a day off work for this installation and would now be forced to take another day off, so after this, how could I be confident that an engineer would actually turn up in a week's time? I then asked for email confirmation of the new appointment so that at least I would have somethnig to refer back to, but was told he could not send an email (somewhat strange for a world-class communication company?) but could send a text confirmation via mobile phone.
I have received this but still have no way of knowing if I'll be taking another day off work for nothing if the Vision engineer does not turn up - and I will still not have the TV service that I am paying for; nor indeed any TV service at all.
I asked for the content of our conversation to be put in writing - either via email or letter - but this was also refused.
I then asked for his superior's name to escalate a complaint and he gave me a (first) name which actually could have been either real or fictitious - I have no idea. I asked to be put through to him but was informed that it would take 48-72 hours to 'raise a form' to be able to do that!
This is totally unnacceptable;  BT has made it my problem that they have failed to keep any record of who this invisible Vision engineer was and I do not see why I should be the one bearing the brunt of this inefficiency.  It is not of my making, neither is it my fault that the installation work is outsourced and as I cannot arrange appointments myself directly, I have no control over the situation and have no choice but to rely on BT to do it correctly on my behalf. I really hope that this is not indicative of things to come, and the kind of service that I left Virgin for. If it is, I will be leaving BT as soon as my contract is up.
PLEASE, is there anything at all that the mods can do (or anyone in the UK that they can refer me to) to sort out this mess, gee things along so I don't have to wait another week when maybe even then no one will turn up to install my Vision service, and tell me how I can make someone actually take ownership of this fiasco? And any other relevant advice?
Most grateful for any help.

If you would like to contact one of the UK based BT Care Team who moderate this forum, they should be able to help you.
They can be contacted using this link BT Care Team
They normally respond by phone or e-mail, within three working days, however you should get an immediate confirmation, with a tracking number.
There are some useful help pages here, for BT Broadband customers only, on my personal website.
BT Broadband customers - help with broadband, WiFi, networking, e-mail and phones.

Similar Messages

  • Primus line rental with bt total broadband is it p...

    I currentley have my line rental and call package billed through BT, and also billed seperatley have the top BT total broadband package, I rarely use the phone and was looking to save money on my line rental.  I am more than happy with my broadband and would like to keep this the same. I have checked the primus website and can get cheaper line rental, and they allow me to keep an alternative broadband provider, however do BT Broadband have any problems with me using someone else for my linerental?

    mykeyb wrote:
    I currentley have my line rental and call package billed through BT, and also billed seperatley have the top BT total broadband package, I rarely use the phone and was looking to save money on my line rental.  I am more than happy with my broadband and would like to keep this the same. I have checked the primus website and can get cheaper line rental, and they allow me to keep an alternative broadband provider, however do BT Broadband have any problems with me using someone else for my linerental?
    Hi mykeyb,
    Unfortunately you need the line rental with BT to have BT broadband,
    You could save some money buy using Line Rental Saver, where you pay a reduced line rental charge up front.
    have a read here:
    http://www.productsandservices.bt.com/consumerProducts/displayTopic.do?topicId=29984
    toekneem
    http://www.no2nuisancecalls.net
    (EASBF)

  • Total Broadband additional usage charges ...

    I'm a loyal BT Phone & Broadband customer (have been for 15 years) and I was somewhat shocked upon receiving my latest quarterly bill to notice that my direct debit payments had been bumped up by quite a bit - closer investigation (of this and the previous bill!) revealed that I've been incurring significant additional broadband charges for at least the last 4 months (as I've exceeded the 10 Gb/month limit on Total Broadband 1).
    I promptly called BT and got upgraded to the Total Broadband 3 package (300 Gb/month limit) and ended up with a cheaper deal all round than I had before!
    This does however leave me about £150 out of pocket and with a slightly bitter taste in my mouth though ...
    Granted, it's my problem for not noticing I'd started going over the 10 Gb/month limit early on [my excuse is that with a very busy life I tend to scan the headline figures on the first page of the bill and only investigate if these seem unusual]
    Nevertheless, I would have expected BT, in the space of the last 6 months, to:
    a) have the courtesy to notify me more proactively that I'm exceeding the "fair usage" policy limits and/or
    b) Move me up to the next level automatically (seeing as it's ended up cheaper anyway?) and/or
    c) Have somebody call me to suggest that I might want to upgrade to save significant costs ...
    Has anybody else had a similar experience ?
    I will add though that I'm very happy with BT's service otherwise - just think this particular point merits raising as a matter of principle!

    Hello alexm3.  Yes, I have had the same problem.  Although I already had a BT landline, I switched in Sep 2010 to a total broadband package Option 1, (at £7.99 p.m.) thinking 10gb was downloads.  Had an email to my normal aol.com account telling me after the first week that I'd used 7gb.  Took 3 weeks to upgrade to Option 2 with 40gb, still went over the usage, and incurred £50 charge, and this month is £20 extra charge, while waiting to upgrade to Option 3.
    I have now been offered Option 3 at £40 p.m. plus line rental of £13.50, plus calls (average £20 p.m.) so look like I am going to be paying over £70 p.m.
    I did also find 22 emails last week in my btinternet.com Inbox although I have indicated I only use my old aol.com email address but they cannot use that although BT have been corresponding with me on that one since day 1 
    Their usage monitor only tells you if you are within or over your usage allowance, not how you've used it!
    Good Luck

  • Mis-sold broadband package? Now stuck with it?

    I feel slightly agrieved at being talked into buying a broadband package with BT on the premise that I could watch European rugby on BT sport for free. I eventually signed up for unlimited infinity 2 and started to enjoy the aforementioned rugby. All was right with the world.
    Then I awoke one day to find that alas BT have paid silly money for the football equivelant and as a result I know have to pay to watch my beloved Rugby. Not only that but I am stuck with 10 months of my 18 months of my contract.
    Why is it that the lure used to buy, what is a slightly more expensive product, Broadband with BT can suddenly be changed mid contract yet I still have to carry on taking the broadband and phone?    
    Apologies if the tone of my post is slightly off but I am slightly miffed. Not only have I been told that I have to pay for something I was told would be free but then I am stuck with BT Infinity now. Any thoughts on what to do?

    hannahe wrote:
    As well as this obvious issue, we have found the whole TV package pretty poor.  The picture quality is worse than normal freeview! Can't get the standard HD channels.  Very difficult to navigate the screens, plus slow response to pressing buttons on remote.
    It sounds like they sent you the BT Vision+ box rather than the BT Youview box. If this is the case was that for a good reason? The newer BT Youview box has a much better interface and will pick up the Freeview HD channels over the TV aerial.
    There are two reasons for still sending out a BT Vision+ box to a new customer.
    (1)  The customer wants to view BT Sport 1 & 2 over the TV aerial as they are not on Infinity broadband. This requires a viewing card slot which the BT Youview box doesn't have.
    (2)  The customer has subscribed to Sky Sports. BT currently can't offer them on the BT Youview box.

  • Upgrading my Broadband package

    Hello,
    My Broadband service was recently switched over from talktalk to BT. I am currently looking into upgrading from the current package that is being received at my residence.
    The current package in my house at the moment is BT total broadband option 1 (with calls and BT vision) with a 10gb monthly download cap, as well as a speed reduction, seeing as I am quite a heavy gamer this has reduced most of my games to a crawl, or a laggy mess.
    So I was wondering, would someone please excuse the simplicity of this question and be able to tell me how much more expensive having unlimited BT infinity with calls and BT vision would be over the current package being used at my home. Seeing as i have been having difficulty getting an exact amount by looking through infomation contained on the BT website.
    We are currently paying around £37 a month for the current package.

    Splat wrote:
    yes, I have been through the process of checking wether my exchange has been upgraded with it, and it has been done rather recently
    The next step then is to go here type in your number and see if your line can receive Infinity, seemples 

  • BT can't find my broadband package - Help/advice n...

    Hello
    So glad I found this forum – I'm in need of some help before I go mad!
    I have been a BT internet customer for nearly 10 years.
    The trouble started at the end of July when I tried to add BT sport free (I have Sky). I couldn't do it online, so I went on online chat and they said I didn't have a broadband account with them. After an hour of me trying to convince them that I am a customer, they finally said they couldn't help me other than to suggest I talk to sales to add broadband to my account – I already have BT broadband!
    I then emailed the residential customer services team via the complaints route to express my dismay at the poor treatment of a long-term loyal customer and to request that they intervene and sort the situation out for me.
    They repeated that I only have landline showing with them and asked whether I had another account number. My internet has always been billed separately to my phone account, but looking through all my documents I couldn't see that I'd ever had an account number for my internet service.
    I discovered when I looked at my account in BT Yahoo email, that I was still on the BT Yahoo Anytime Plus service, but there was no account number to be seen anywhere. Like many people on this forum I received occasional emails from BT at the end of 2011 saying that I would be transferred to BT Total Broadband Option 1 at some point, but this obviously never happened.
    On reading this forum I discovered that there are a number of people like me who have 'unaligned' accounts where they're still on an old service that is billed separately and not linked to their MyBT account. I also read on this forum that someone had managed to find their separate internet account number by checking their bank statement direct debit info. I did this and managed to find an account number (starting GB followed by 8 numbers) but I've tried to use it online myself and it isn't recognised, so I've emailed the residential services team with this number.
    They haven't replied to me yet – it's well past the 72 hours they're supposed to reply in – and I've got a strong feeling they're just going to say they can't find the account number on their system. If they reply at all.
    Interestingly, I went onto my BT Yahoo email account page today and my internet product had changed from BT Yahoo Anytime Plus to BT Total Broadband Option 1.
    Now, I don't know if my message has triggered some action at BT's end, but if it has they haven't told me. My big concern now is that my BT Yahoo Anytime Plus was unlimited with no contract and it now looks like I've been moved to a product with a tiny 10GB limit. I run an online business so I'm rarely offline and I'd exceed my limit within a few days. I'm worried that I'm already exceeding my usage, and if I hadn't looked I wouldn't even know I'd been moved.
    All I want is for BT to recognise and merge my accounts, and then I can upgrade to an unlimited package (which will cost less than what I'm paying now anyway). And then I can also add BT Sport, to which I'm entitled and not able to get because BT's systems are rubbish.
    I'd thought about simply cancelling my existing direct debit and ordering a new broadband package, but I really need to keep my email address as I've had it for years and I use it for business.
    I've seen that there are lovely mods on this forum who can help, so I'm hoping one can come to my rescue before I pull all my hair out – I've got nowhere so far and it's been more than 6 weeks since my intial contact with BT.
    Apologies for the length of this message!
    Many Thanks,
    Justine
    Solved!
    Go to Solution.

    Hello again
    Can anybody tell me how long it normally takes for the mods to reply to a contact form please?  I submitted an enquiry via RobbieMacs's profile link on 18 September and have not yet received a reply or acknowledgement.  Does it normally take a few days to hear back from them?
    My problem has also worsened.  As I mentioned above, someone has been tinkering with my account because last week I was moved without warning from BT Yahoo Anytime plus service to BT Total Broadband Option 1, without being informed.  Then on Friday I received a 'Welcome to BT Broadband' email (I've had BT Broadband for nearly 10 years!), and last night I for the first time ever in nearly 10 years I received a usage warning.
    So, not only has my account been moved without telling me, but I've been moved from an unlimited service to a capped service (for the same price) and I'm close to reaching my limiit after a few days usage.
    But, despite the behind-the-scenes tinkering, my internet product still hasn't been merged with MyBT account so I cannot access it online to upgrade to an unlimited package, and I cannot call them as they will just tell me they have no record of me having broadband with them (I've been told this too many times over the last few weeks and it drives me crazy everytime - it's as if they think I'm making it up!).
    I'm so close to jumping ship to Virgin, and I think if I start incurring extra usage charges because I've been moved on to a product I currently have no control over, it may well be the last straw!
    Thanks,
    Justine

  • Upgrading Broadband Package

    I'm trying to upgrade from BT Total Broadband Option 2 to the Unlimited Broadband package. However, when I check out it says that the package is unavailable and I have no idea why. Am I not able to upgrade or is it just an error with BT?

    To upgrade follow these links.
    http://www.productsandservices.bt.com/consumerProducts/displayTopic.do?topicId=25633&s_cid=con_ppc_m...
    They might tell you this deal is for new customers only and that an existing customer has to upgrade via this link
    http://www.productsandservices.bt.com/consumerProducts/displayTopic.do?topicId=27281
    which costs more but I'm sure if you haggle with them and point out that you are a loyal customer and will stay loyal at least for the length of the contract they will do a deal.
    If you can't get the links to work contact the options team 0800 800 030  they are UK based

  • BT Total Broadband

    Hi,
    Anybody in the UK got BT Total Broadband yet? How well does this work with your Mac and which package would you recommend? Is the one with the phone worth the extra (need a new phone anyway)? I already have an airport base station and an ibook and will at some point get a macbook...
    Thanks

    Hi Stuart,
    Now that BT are issuing ethernet ADSL modems/routers there service is proving to be ok for Mac users. I have setup a few of there yoyager modems and wifi routers and they come with an easy to use setup disk. Setting up their internet phone devices may require you to call their tech support.
    There voip service is not the cheapest available there are other service you can use.
    Now to get a feel of what other users are saying abou† the service why not have a look at the forums at the adslguide.
    http://bbs.adslguide.org.uk/postlist.php?Cat=&Board=bt

  • Total Broadband Anywhere dongle expired (I think)

    I think the free period of usage of my BT Total Broadband Anywhere dongle might have run out.  Is there anywhere online that i can confirm this?  I thought there might have been a promotion to encourage to extend it in some way.
    It connects to the network but then no connection to the Internet.
    I am not seeing any WiFi signals on the donge either but that could be because of clashed with the internal WiFi on my PC.  I will check on another PC later.
    I don't tend to use the 3G connection very often so will have to look around for the best package for occasional use but wanted to check my status first.
    MB
    MB

    Raid1968 wrote:
    If you've registered you should be able to see under your account on BT.COM, also there is no built in wifi on the dongle, the connection manager software utilises the wifi already on your PC/Laptop.
    Failing that contact the mobile service department 08007832326
    Raid
    Thanks, I will look into that.  Sure I registered it when I first got it.
    I had got the idea that there was WiFi in the dongle but obviously mistaken.
    MB
    MB

  • BT broadband package is a CON

    I only sgined up so that I can put a post here to say how 'disgusted' I'm with BT and to tell others not to sign up to the BT broadband package. 
    I signed up to the usual £13 a month broadband package in November 2011.  It was an 18 month contract paying £13 a month. However, on checking my account just now I found that I was being charged £13.75 a month from January 2013 onward.  Called BT customer service twice and on both times I was basically told that there was nothing to be done about it and that there was a clause 48?? somewhere that allowed them to up the price anytime.  And that I was told about the changes.  I told them I did receive an email about line rental and calll charges but NOTHING about the broadband increase.   Anyhow, all they could say was that there was nothing to be done about it.  If I want to cancel the contract there was termination fees etc.   However I had just renewed and paid for another year of line rental in advance otherwise I would have no hesitation in leaving this 'con' of a company
    I'm totally **bleep** off with the whole thing.  The increase is not massive but had I known I wouldn't have renewed a year of line rental and get stuck with a 'con' for another year.  BT is a con, especially as everywhere you look, they're still advertising the £13 a month broadband package.  So beware people, don't sign up to it. Prices could go up anytime.

    I agree.  Seems a very one-side contract... and one that cost to terminate.  I received the email, but to find out the changes you needed to go to a website... that my PC thought was dodgy and recommended that I did not open it!
    Like you, I also paid for the year's line rental upfront and making it difficult to change contracts.  Doesn't this contravene the Competition rules.
    Perhaps the thing to do is to make a complaint to OFCOM - http://consumers.ofcom.org.uk/tell-us/telecoms/
    And while we are at it... isn't it somewhat unreasonable to read pages and pages of small print to find the 'catches'?

  • BT total broadband option 3 general questions

    Potential new customer here but got some questions after speaking to BT customer services who have totally confused me so not exactly a good start.
    I am looking at bt total broadband option 3 for 19.99 a month for 3 months and 27.99 there after and would love it if someone could clarify the following.
    1. Does this package really come with unlimited wifi (openzone, fon) as BT customer services told me this is extra?
    2. If I take out the mobile broadband option with 1gb is that a one time offer or do I get 1gb free each month?
    3. If I ever go over the FUP of 300gb is it true my broadband will be throttled for 30 days?
    Hopefully someone can clarify these questions for me.
    Happy New Year!!!
    Dale
    Solved!
    Go to Solution.

    cameron1590 wrote:
    3. if you go over the FUP your speed will get throttled from the point you broke it to the start of the next bill date so for example your bill dates is the 23rd of every month and you went over on the 15th your speed would be rock bottom till the 23rd.
    Hi.
    AFAIK the "peak times throttling" applies for 30 days, not until the billing start date. See :-
    http://www.bt.com/broadbandusagepolicy
    section 4.
    http://www.andyweb.co.uk/shortcuts
    http://www.andyweb.co.uk/pictures

  • Total Broadband Anywhere

    I am on the Total Broadband Anywhere package and I use an HTC Hero mobile phone.  If I decide to cancel the mobile phone element of the contract, how will this impact on the cost of the package and will BT be prepared to issue a PAC to enable me to acquire another phone from a different provider?  Any help will be greatly appreciated.

    If you are on the minimum 50 minutes and 50 texts a month, then you should see a reduction of about £5, however you may be able to negotiate an even better reduction if you are prepared to renew your broadband contract.
    You should have no trouble getting a PAC code so you can port your number.
    There are some useful help pages here, for BT Broadband customers only, on my personal website.
    BT Broadband customers - help with broadband, WiFi, networking, e-mail and phones.

  • !!! Statements of Logic Deleting Files and messing with System are True !!!

    This morning I answered some guys post about Logic deleting everything in the same level as the project folder under certain circumstances. I Tried trouble shooting for him but could not recreate it.
    Then this happened to me today:
    When working in Logic 8 in Leopard all of a sudden it stopped communicating with my Unitor8 via USB. I restarted but the Unitor 8 Which I reset twice would NOT communicate with L8 anymore. It would remain in patch mode (red light lit though CPU is running)
    I've had this erratic behavior many times since the past years on many computers so it wasn't really new. All one needs to do is reinstall the Unitor Family driver.
    So I decided to do so:
    I inserted my Logic Studio DVD and opened the installer and checked ONLY the Unitor family Drivers. After completed install I restarted the Mac. Everything went fine. So I booted L8. While booting I saw my hardrives on the right side of the desktop flash once. I thought that to be strange and took closer look.
    Now my boot drive was missing from all the drives on the desktop and in the sidebar window...
    I tried to Apple+Click on a Application in the dock. The finder opened the applications folder and showed me the app I had clicked on. But I could not navigate to the root of my System Drive even via the "path" sysmbol in the toolbar. So I hit shiftappleg and entered /Volumes/MySystemVolume - it showed my volume "Grayed Out" in the finder window...
    I tried repairing the disk and permissions but nothing was wrong with my boot drive apparently besides the fact that the finder (and all other applications when wanting to open or save) could not "see" my system drive... I could launch all the apps normally that were residing on the SystemDrive in the AppFolder... So this kept getting weirder...
    So I opened my favorite application Tinkertool System and went to the Tab Files and chose the underlying tab "Attributes" which shows me Macintosh HFS and Finder Attributes... I pulled my SystemDrive onto the Drop Area and discovered something VERY amazing: The Display in Finder option had mysteriously been altered to "INVISIBLE"
    I changed it to Visible and there it was - My System Drive... Showing up in the finder...
    I made a restart to make sure everything was OK....
    After the restart the following settings had VANISHED:
    1) Pixadex = ALL ICONS (I had 230 MB) of sorted icons stored in my Application Support Folder
    2) All my Safari Book marks were gone - They were still in ~/Library/Safari - but the Bookmarks.plist was UNREADABLE even with a text editor and XML editor
    3) Numerous other applications had LOST their authorization preferences so I had to re-authorize many of my Audio Unit plug-ins...
    4) My Dock had been reset
    5) My Monitor arrangement had been reset...
    6) My date and time had been reset
    7) My energy settings had been reset.... (I had NOT zapped the P-RAM)
    Since installing Leopard 2 weeks ago - I have CAREFULLY monitored ANY activity after INSTALLING anything in order to be able to troubleshoot - and this problem definitely occurred right after installing the USB Family Drivers and launching L8....
    There was really NO HARM done other than the sweating that I did troubleshooting but if L8 is capable of doing what happened to this other guy loosing his whole folder and now doing this to me - where are the limits? When is someone going to get REAL hurt.
    Please Apple - I am sending you this post as a BUG report as well - could you PLEASE look into this as there has to be some kind of VERY dangerous MALFUNCTION within Logic or its Installers.

    Wow, I was just joking with the medication thing. I didn't actually think it was seriously a mental health issue. Sorry.
    In any case, though, if he has full access to the Mac, mental health issues or no, there's not a whole lot to do about it. If it is possible to take away administrative privileges without causing a huge fuss, then you can limit his access to certain things. However, you can't mess with privileges on a Time Machine backup (doing so breaks it), and that means he's going to have access to at least parts of the backup. Which means he can trash at least some of the backup data, and if he deletes files from the TM backup using the Finder, he'll have essentially trashed the whole backup. He might as well have the ability to delete all the files on the machine if he has the power to delete backups.
    Honestly, in this situation, he should either only be allowed to use an account with Parental Controls on, which may not be an option (I don't know how offended he would be at such a suggestion), or he should be using a different computer entirely and have no access at all to his wife's computer. Alternately, have his wife keep a backup that is hidden - ie, connect the backup drive periodically and then remove it and hide it so he can't mess with it. That will at least secure the backup.

  • Trying to change broadband package

    I've been trying to change my broadband package for over a month now.  I'm still on the old Option 3 unlimited broadband, I want to be on the current Unlimited broadband package which is half the price for the same service (£16 versus £30.50).  I sent an email and received a callback over a month ago and was advised that changes had been made.  I checked last week and I was still on the old Option 3, after going on Live Chat I was told it would be resolved and I'd receive an email to tell me when it was changed.  No email received by today so went on Live Chat again and they confirmed that no changes had been made but this time were very evasive and again wanted me to wait to be contacted.  I can understand why BT would want me paying double for the same service but surely they can't just ignore my requests?
    Can a mod help please?  I've tried the Complaints section on the Contact Us form but it just directs you back to the same customer service teams which haven't done anything so far.

    Hi sd7,
    Thanks for posting and apologies that this is going on for so long.
    I can help you with your package from here.  To get in touch, click on the "about me" section of my profile where you'll see the link to "contact the mods".
    Whenever we've received your details we'll take it from there.
    Thanks a million,
    Robbie
    BTCare Community Mod
    If we have asked you to email us with your details, please make sure you are logged in to the forum, otherwise you will not be able to see our ‘Contact Us’ link within our profiles.
    We are sorry that we are unable to deal with service/account queries via the private message(PM) function so please don't PM your account info, we need to deal with this via our email account :-)
    If someone answers your question correctly please let other members know by clicking on ’Mark as Accepted Solution’.

  • Test results showing how FCP7 running on 10.6 messes with gamma

    I've been running some simple tests to determine how FCP7 handles gamma when running 10.6.4.
    Note that 10.6.4 now uses a gamma of 2.2 natively (as do PCs).
    I created three images in targa, png and tif (also tried exr, but FCP won't read that) that contained squares colored in different shades of gray, solid colors and mixed colors.
    This download link is good for 7 days:
    https://www.yousendit.com/directDownload?phi_action=app/directDownload&fl=SWhZek ZpTk1IcWR1a29CcFA0aU9SMHVDeVNFRkF0Qm1kRmM2aXU1dg
    When I brought these into FCP, the results were not good.
    FCP changed the gamma considerably on them, so that all the colors were WAY off (127,127,127 became 145,145,145)
    I was able to ALMOST fix this by applying a gamma filter (NOT the gamma correction filter, totally different) with a value of .82.
    Now, in a 0.255 scale, my values were only off by one.
    However, that is a massive color shift for anyone dealing with color management.
    1. Is there a way to bring in an image sequence so that FCP does NOT tamper with the gamma?
    2. If I must gamma correct, is there a 3rd party plug-in with more significant digits? I need more digits than .82.
    I also did some testing on Quicktime.
    QT10 is a total mess. When I output to a non-self-contained mov (after gamma correcting), it was WAY off.
    QT7 is on the mark and matches what VLC shows.
    The same goes for outputting to H.264. QT7 = good, QT10 = BAD.
    I suppose I'll experiment with Compressor now to see the proper values to get ALMOST back to my original colors.
    Hopefully I'm missing some hidden setting for 'give me back my original gamma'.
    BTW - you can open the images I supplied in Photoshop to see the correct values.
    Using the 'digital color meter' included with 10.6 is a quick way to determine the RGB values that are displayed on the screen in FCP, QT and other programs.
    And a value of 127,127,127 is just an absolute value, doesn't really matter if you have a $10K reference monitor to display it on (although, I'm sure the same RGB values would look different on the reference monitor).
    BTW, FCP7 and 10.5 also mess with gamma.

    As I had such dismal results with getting h.264 from FCP7/Compressor to match my input colors when viewed in VLC and the Quicktime player, I decided to try using Premiere CS4.
    Both Premiere CS4/AME and FCP7/Compressor produced h.264 that was pretty far off when viewed in VLC and the Quicktime player7, although CS4/AME was a bit closer.
    As my final output is often intended for the web, I decided to try the same files when displayed using the latest Flash player.
    The results were interesting.
    The Premiere CS4 results were all within 1 value of being correct. 127,127,127 would end up as 126,126,126 - and the same for the other shades of grey and color combinations.
    But the FCP7/Compressor display was a disaster. 63,63,63 displayed as 81,81,81.
    127,127,127 displayed as 144,144,144.
    So, at least for Flash viewing of videos on the web, FCP/Compressor just couldn't produce accurate colors, they were all WAY off.
    I'll have to try the same tests for DVD and BluRay.
    BTW - this is the very simple image I used for testing (this display is a png, I used a tga for the actual tests to eliminate any possibility of a color profile getting embedded by mistake).
    http://i34.tinypic.com/29lbgo7.png
    This link with the original files is valid until aug 12:
    https://www.yousendit.com/directDownload?phi_action=app/directDownload&fl=SWhZek ZpTk1IcWR1a29CcFA0aU9SMHVDeVNFRkF0Qm1kRmM2aXU1dg

Maybe you are looking for