Second disk (HDD) spins down occasionally, ignoring energy setting.

I've UNCHECKED the setting "Put the hard disk(s) to sleep when possible" because I find no value in this. Yet my second disk (HDD) occasionally spins down when the computer is left idle for a while. (My first disk is an SSD). It's all apple-made, no custom or user changes inside. It's not a big deal, but I know spinning down and up again adds wear to the disk and it's something I'd rather not have the disk doing. It's ignoring the setting, why is this? and can I do something about it?

I was affraid that would be the case, blah! Well it's an HDD so I can hear it click when it spins down and back up. It's mostly just happening when the computer is idle for a long time but it's still a wasteful act because it usually spins right back up again after a while and it SEEMS this time around it won't wait equally long before it spins down again but does so relatively quickly again as if the drive figured something minor just happened and that it can just go "back to sleep" when it's done, which on it's turn adds to the wear if I'd leave it like this for hours on since SOME activity is always present from time to time on any disk.

Similar Messages

  • HDD Spin Down - Storage Spaces

    I would like to know if anybody got some kind of solution, or has gotten any further then me.  
    I want to build an application that can monitor you HDD energy consumption. (spin down status)  and the temperature. 
    I've figured out how to get the temperature from WMI   but the spin down status is proving to be kind of impossible.
    http://superuser.com/questions/400213/see-if-hdd-is-in-sleep-mode-for-windows
    I understand the only windows has control over the HDD spin down of each drive.   The problem is , if I have a drive that is spun down, and i start to try and get the information about its status using WMI,  the drive is spinning back up. 
    Also , i want to monitor Storage Spaces individual drive status.   If i'm making a storage space jbod, (no redundancy),  I would like to know the hdd spinning status of each drive.

    Maybe use a
    performance counter and if the disk is idle for some time then you should know it is spun down I suppose. Although you would have to test that. And the app probably requires admin privileges to access that info.
    Run below code with admin privileges. Select button1 to fill ListBox1. Selected item in ListBox1, select Button2 to fill ListBox2. Select item in ListBox2, select Button3 to fill ListBox3. Start timer.
    Stop timer to begin new selection process from ListBox1 for ListBox2 and ListBox3 or leave timer running if changing selection in ListBox3.
    Option Strict On
    Public Class Form1
    'Code used is from below two links.
    'Walkthrough: Retrieving Categories and Counters
    'http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/2fh4x1xb(v=vs.90).aspx
    'A Quick Introduction to Performance Counters in Visual Studio 2012
    'http://www.codeguru.com/columns/vb/a-quick-introduction-to-performance-counters-in-visual-studio-2012.htm
    Private pc As PerformanceCounter
    Private Sub Form1_Load(sender As Object, e As EventArgs) Handles MyBase.Load
    Me.Location = New Point(CInt((Screen.PrimaryScreen.WorkingArea.Width / 2) - (Me.Width / 2)), CInt((Screen.PrimaryScreen.WorkingArea.Height / 2) - (Me.Height / 2)))
    Me.Text = "Performance Counters"
    ListBox1.Sorted = True
    ListBox2.Sorted = True
    ListBox3.Sorted = True
    Button4.BackColor = Color.Lime
    Button4.Text = "Start Timer"
    Timer1.Interval = 1000
    End Sub
    Private Sub Button1_Click(sender As Object, e As EventArgs) Handles Button1.Click
    Dim myCat As PerformanceCounterCategory()
    Dim i As Integer
    ListBox1.Items.Clear()
    myCat = PerformanceCounterCategory.GetCategories
    For i = 0 To myCat.Length - 1
    ListBox1.Items.Add(myCat(i).CategoryName)
    Next
    End Sub
    Dim InstanceNames() As String
    Private Sub Button2_Click(sender As Object, e As EventArgs) Handles Button2.Click
    ListBox2.Items.Clear()
    If ListBox1.SelectedIndex <> -1 Then
    Dim mycat As New PerformanceCounterCategory(ListBox1.SelectedItem.ToString())
    InstanceNames = mycat.GetInstanceNames()
    If InstanceNames.Count > 0 Then
    For Each Item In InstanceNames
    ListBox2.Items.Add(Item)
    Next
    End If
    End If
    End Sub
    Dim Counters As New System.Collections.ArrayList
    Private Sub Button3_Click(sender As Object, e As EventArgs) Handles Button3.Click
    ListBox3.Items.Clear()
    Counters.Clear()
    If ListBox1.SelectedIndex <> -1 And ListBox2.SelectedIndex <> -1 Then
    Dim mycat As New PerformanceCounterCategory(ListBox1.SelectedItem.ToString())
    Counters.AddRange(mycat.GetCounters(ListBox2.SelectedItem.ToString))
    Dim counter As PerformanceCounter
    For Each counter In Counters
    ListBox3.Items.Add(counter.CounterName)
    Next
    End If
    End Sub
    Private Sub Button4_Click(sender As Object, e As EventArgs) Handles Button4.Click
    If Button4.Text = "Start Timer" Then
    Button4.BackColor = Color.OrangeRed
    Button4.Text = "Stop Timer"
    Timer1.Start()
    Else
    Button4.BackColor = Color.Lime
    Button4.Text = "Start Timer"
    Timer1.Stop()
    End If
    End Sub
    Private Sub Timer1_Tick(sender As Object, e As EventArgs) Handles Timer1.Tick
    RichTextBox1.Text = ""
    If ListBox1.SelectedIndex <> -1 And ListBox2.SelectedIndex <> -1 And ListBox3.SelectedIndex <> -1 Then
    pc = New PerformanceCounter()
    pc.CategoryName = ListBox1.SelectedItem.ToString
    pc.InstanceName = ListBox2.SelectedItem.ToString
    pc.CounterName = ListBox3.SelectedItem.ToString
    RichTextBox1.AppendText(pc.CounterHelp.ToString & vbCrLf & vbCrLf & vbCrLf & "RawValue = " & pc.RawValue.ToString & vbCrLf & "NextValue = " & pc.NextValue.ToString)
    End If
    End Sub
    End Class
    La vida loca

  • T440p secondary HDD spins down

    Hello,
    In my T440p, I replaced the HDD with a SSD, and put the HDD in a caddy (bought from hddcaddy.com). My problem is that after booting, right at the Windows login-screen, the HDD spins down ~1 out of 5 times. I can't find it in disk management after that happens. When the HDD does keep spinning after login, it works fine.
    What I know is that the cause of the problem isn't the caddy, neither the HDD. HDDcaddy sent me a second caddy, and I tried with different HDD's. So it must be software-related.
    I played around in the BIOS, but nothing seemed to work. (BTW, instead of the 'ThinkPad' loading screen, I now have a 'Lenovo' loading screen while booting. What's causing that?)
    Does anybody experiences the same problem as me? Because I couldn't find anything on the forum. Help is appreciated.
    Greetings
    ThinkPad T440p 20AN006VMH - Win 8.1 - i7 4700MQ - SSD: 250 GB Samsung 840 EVO (internal) - 500 GB SATA 7200rpm (HDD caddy)

    My T440p has a spinner in a Lenovo Ultrabay, the system drive is a Toshiba SSD that I ordered with the system.  I do not have the same problem. 
    Some differences in setup, however:  I use fingerprint authentication at boot, that carries through to Windows login, and I am using Win 7 Pro. 
    I set the drive timeout to spin it down purposely once Windows is loaded, but otherwise it starts spinning and stays spinning on power up.

  • Stop external disk drives spinning down

    Just got a new imac 27" - dlighted with it in every way :-)   10.7.1
    All my backup drives are external of course. Mostly OWC FireWire.
    In the past have used SpinDownFix to keep 'em rolling so that there's no wait while they all start up every time anything needs to access the FileSystem.
    But I can't help thinking there must be a better way.
    Anyone know of one, please for Lion?
    TUA!

    Hi Mark,
    Energy Saver box unchecked... and my 3 externals ( 2 x FW 800, 1 x USB ) keep spinning on my iMac...
    Do your Ext HDs have any proprietary software installed on them...?
    If so, this could be why they keep spinning down...
    Cheers

  • Can I spin down my internal disk? Open Firmware or terminal commands?

    Hello all,
    I have not been around here for a while, but I desperately need your help.
    Does anyone know how I can spin down my internal disk?
    Possibly with the terminal or Open Firmware?
    Does anyone know all the Open Firmware commands or
    where a list can be found so that I can explore the situation myself?
    Here is some more detail of what I want to do and why.
    My internal disk crashed a while ago.
    (My bag slid off my shoulder and the machine hit the brick sidewalk below right on its' corner:>(
    I have since been running off my little pocket-size fire-wire disk.
    Today the internal disk finally really bit the dust and the bearings are making quite a noise.
    (If I tip the PB while it is running the noise turns into a whine of varying pitch and loudness.
    It sounds like my poor PB is crying in pain. LOL)
    I want to get the internal disk to spin down until I can afford a new one and I have the time to replace it.
    Any ideas?
    I know I could open up the case and pull the plug on it,
    but maybe there is something better and easier.
    Can anyone guide me in any possible terminal commands to eject it or
    give some insight into firmware commands that may help?
    I know the firmware can spin the disk down. - It does so for power management.
    Also, one time when I booted, the disk gave the boot process such a bad error that
    the boot process asked me what to do. I told it to eject the disk - then the disk spun down
    and the machine booted normally off the FW disk.
    So, maybe there is an Open Firmware command I could use to permanently shut the thing off.
    I cannot use the Disk Utility to unmount or eject it.
    In Disk Utility, sometimes the disk is already unmounted and grayed out.
    So therefor the unmount and eject commands are also greyed out.
    At other times the disk does not even show up in Disk Utility.
    Thanks, Bob

    Thanks for the fast response.
    Although your suggestion did not do the trick, it jogged my old mind into
    finding a solution that does work. Or seems to work for right now.
    The 'drutil' is a command for CD-R/RW media, so it could not see or act on my internal hard drive.
    Your suggestion to use a disk utility command sent me off to find a command for other devices and
    I remembered the 'diskutil' command.
    I did a 'diskutil list' and after a good wait for the failed disk to allow completion,
    I was given a list that showed what device the internal disk was (/dev/disk2).
    I then did a 'diskutil eject /dev/disk2' and after a similar wait, the disk was ejected and it spun down.
    It was a pleasant surprise since the drive is not ejectable and since the OsX Disk Utility could not eject it.
    There are things (running the disk utility) that do seem to wake up the disk occasionally,
    but all I have to do is issue the command again.
    Thanks
    p.s. Perhaps I was not clear in my original question that
    I wanted to spin down my internal ide hard disk - sorry if that was a confusion.
    p.p.s. It is also very interesting that I called Apple support and
    they could not give me this simple solution.

  • Hard Disks Spinning Down

    Apologies if this has been answered.
    In the Energy Saver preferences, I have unchecked the preference to spin down the hard disks (put them to sleep). But even so, the disks still spin down, which leaves me staring at the beach ball several times a day. I have the other preferences set to sleep both the system and display after 1 hour.
    Is there a way in 10.4.6 to keep the disks from spinning down?
    QuickSilver   Mac OS X (10.4.6)  

    I have the same problem with a similar, if not identical, computer.
    I have unchecked "put hard disks to sleep" in the Energy Saver and trashed the preferences (Library/Preferences/SystemConfiguration/com.apple.PowerManagement.plist)
    The problem still happens. Can anyone help?

  • USB disk won't spin down

    I tried asking this in the iMac forum, but as it seems to be a software issue, I hope you don't mind me posting it here:
    I have a new iMac and a Lacie Blade Runner external 4TB USB 3.0 drive.  Unfortunately when I power off the Mac, the Lacie keeps spinning and will not power down - very annoying.
    Here's the strange thing though.   When connected to my Mac Mini, the drive does power down properly when I shut the Mini down.  (Both Macs are on 10.8.4).  Also, when I power the iMac down in Bootcamp, the drive also spins down properly.  So it does not appear to be a hardware issue.
    I have "put the drives to sleep" (or whatever it is called) checked, btw.
    Also, the disk will spin down if I put the iMac to sleep.  It's only when I shutdown the iMac fully that the Lacie drive keeps spinning forever.
    Any ideas how to get the external drive to power off properly when I shut down?

    Is bumping allowed ;-)
    Come on chaps - does no-one have any ideas?  My drive is unusable if I have to keep turning it on and off all the time!  How do I get an external USB drive to power off when I switch off my iMac?  Surely there's something I can check?
    My Mac Mini shuts it down just fine, but the iMac won't.  Both on 10.8.4.
    Any ideas?

  • WRT160NL: Automatic spin-down of external USB hard disks?

    Hello,
    do external hard disks automatically spin down after a period with no access/use when connected with the USB port of the WRT160NL?

    In reference to your post could you please let me know that when you say "spin down" do you mean that does the hard drive goes into sleep mode when it is not in use?
    Did you try to connect another hard drive and check whether it is the same case or not?

  • Making my external not able to spin-down

    Hey all,
    I've got a portable hard drive that's kinda screwed up, and won't spin up correctly 95% of times I try to start it (I've sat there for hours trying to get it to start powering on and off). I need to get it replaced, but until then...
    Anyways, I use it to run live media to a projector for events, and if I leave it alone, it spins down and I can't get it back online when I need it. Is there something I can do that will specify that disk not to spin down? (even if I have to redo it if it changes the mounting drive spec.) It's currently usually set as /dev/disk1s2, so use that to reference the command (I'll probably have to change it as it changes with my setup).
    Sorry if this is all horribly confusing. I saw some other forums, but nothing specified which disk shouldn't spin down.

    Nah, the energy saver options only specify to internal drives. Does anyone know any UNIX commands that would help? I've seen tons of message boards of UNIX commands to keep a drive spinning, but never one for an external drive.

  • AEBS prevents my USB drive from spinning down

    Hi all,
    I thought I would share my concerns about connecting USB external drive with AirPort Extreme. I've seen several post here talking about that issue, but they didn't solve my problem.
    Otherwise great product, AirPort Extreme n prevents my WD MyBook 500GB disk from spinning down when not in use. I bought that particular disc, because of its ability to go to sleep when not accessed for a period of time. It works great when connected to my MacBook via FW400 or USB 2.0, but when I use it via AiPort Disk utility and connect to AEBS the disk will not spin down, keep running and getting hot. I am concerned with that fact, because it consumes more energy and will shorten disc life (yes, it is not a server graded disc, as most of USB ones, and it was not designed to spin continously).
    I read some posts about Spotlight indexing the drive, but that is not true because of three facts:
    - when connected via USB 2.0 or FW400 the disc spins down.
    - when I left it for two hours it was still spinning - Spotlight should have finished indexing by then right?
    - even if I eject network drives from the Desktop, breaking the connection with my MB it is still spinning.
    There seems to be a problem with AE itself. AEBS seem to keep the disc busy all the time or the disc thinks that's the situation.
    From what I've read this is not MyBook only case. People with Lacie, Maxtor and other brands are having the same problem.
    At this point I have no solution to this. I disconnected the drive and access it via FW400 only. That's a shame, because Apple advertises AirPort Extreme using USB drive connectivity as a major selling point. I think that situation is unacceptable. A disc spinning 24/7 is asking for trouble.
    If someone has a solution to that problem, please share it with the forum readers, if not we will have to wait for Apple to fix this. I hope someone from Apple is reading this.
    MacBook C2D   Mac OS X (10.4.9)  

    Otherwise great product, AirPort Extreme n prevents
    my WD MyBook 500GB disk from spinning down when not
    in use. I bought that particular disc, because of its
    ability to go to sleep when not accessed for a period
    of time.
    Other posts indicate you can solve this by privatizing the drive in Spotlight's preferences. I haven't tried this because I like the drive indexed--it is a shared data drive after all.
    I turn the drive off manually when I'm not using it. Unfortunately, the Airport doesn't recognize the drive (or printers that I've turned off, for that matter) when I turn it back on. The only solution I've found is to restart the Airport. Any ideas on this problem?

  • Lenovo Iomega 70A29000EA - does Twonky block spin-down of drives

    Hi team,
    I am concerned that my NAS never spins down the drives (current setting is 15 mins), can you please advise on how I can check if it does and whether the twonky settings or remote access (I am not using the personal cloud but I access it through my static ip) somehow affect that?
    I always thought that the NAS will go to sleep and wake-on-lan or soemthing whenever accessed remotely
    thanks
    Solved!
    Go to Solution.

    Hello tournas
    Having Twonky (media server) enabled on the NAS or linking the NAS to a desktop version of Twonky server can cause the energy savings configuration to be ignored.  
    Normally personal cloud would also cause the same situation, however if you have not configured your device for personal cloud or have your cloud disabled there should not be a problem.  Manually connecting via the external ip would not affect the energy savings.  
    Other items to check on this would be Active folders from the Shares page and Torrents(transmission).  If those options are enabled and or in use they could prevent the energy savings to work.  
    In some cases having shares mapped/mounted to a client desktop/workstation can prevent the energy savings from working as well.   You may also want to try cycling all of the protocols off/on in case a protocol happens to be malfunctioning.
    LenovoEMC Contact Information is region specific. Please select the correct link then access the Contact Us at the top right:
    US and Canada: https://lenovo-na-en.custhelp.com/
    Latin America and Mexico: https://lenovo-la-es.custhelp.com/
    EU: https://lenovo-eu-en.custhelp.com/
    India/Asia Pacific: https://lenovo-ap-en.custhelp.com/
    http://support.lenovoemc.com/

  • Spin down / spin up External HD

    Morning all,
    I'm hoping someone can help me out on a request.
    I currently run four external HD's at home, each with there own tasks and storage needs. I have set (using pmset in Terminal) my discs spin down times to 5 mins rather than 10, so these sleep quicker than normal when not used. I'd like to be able to spin down / spin up these disc's on instruction, rather than waiting the 5 mins.
    I have put together Applescripts which I then build into Automator which I can run from Finder, and would like to have a simular script to spin down / up the drives on instruction.
    I'm very new to writing scripts so this maybe something simple, but I just can't find a solution. Anyone got any ideas ?
    Many thanks in advance.
    Neil Holmes.

    Sorry, I misunderstood you to already have the commands you needed for pmset, so I didn't look too closely at that command.
    What I have determined is that you don't have the ability to force the disk to spin down immediately - but rather, as you have already discovered, to set the idle duration before it will spin down; the minimum being one minute. (I also noticed that to make a setting stick you need administrator permissions, so I have included that syntax here.)
    I am not sure if this gets you any further forward, but the AppleScript syntax to spin down after one minute idle would be*:
    do shell script "pmset -a disksleep 1" user name "<adminuser>" password "<adminpass>" with administrator privileges
    and setting to never spin down would be*:
    do shell script "pmset -a disksleep 0" user name "<adminuser>" password "<adminpass>" with administrator privileges
    I am probably being stupid here, but wouldn't it be dangerous if you were able to spin down the disk on command?
    *In each case, open Script Editor, cut-n-paste the text between the lines and amend for your username and password - retaining the double quotation marks, but not the braces - and click run.

  • WRT610N with power saving spin down hard drive

    Hi,
    Has anyone used the WRT610N with a storage drive that auto spins down?  I find the router works fine accessing the HDD until left idle when the HDD spins down.  The next time I try to access the HDD and of course there's a lag as the drive spins back up, I get some type of freezing, usually the USB light on the router turns off, the HDD light stays on and the router loses connection the HDD.
    Any help here???
    Also, despite gigabit ethernet and 802.11n speeds, I get around 2 Mb/s speeds to the USB storage port.  A little slow no???
    Yes, I have the latest firmware.

    Connect your HDD directly to a computer and check if you face the same problem, I think there is a problem with your HDD...

  • Need external HDs to spin down

    Hi to everybody, I apologize if this ain't the right setionfor my topic as it is highy related to hardware and just a little to SL.
    This is my problem: I took a couple of WD 500 Gbyte and placed them in a single box each. I the did a software RAID0 within Disk Utility.
    Both disk are stil working fast but do NEVER spin down even if my iMac is shut down.
    I found several utilities to prevent HDs from spinning down but non for forcing them to spin down after a certain idle time. I also set 5 minutes of idle time to spin down with Xcode's utility HDSpindown but nothing changes.
    Any help?
    TIA
    Simon

    Just out of curiosity, can you tell me the utilities that keep disks from spinning down? I have a drive in my Pro that's spinning down and it's driving me crazy. I've contacted the manufacturers and Seagate has no solutions and WDC suggested I buy a PC. You know what I told them.
    Thanks

  • HDD ridiculous parking (spinning down) and clicking issue

    I have an original Macbook Pro (Santa Rosa) with upgraded hdd Seagate Momentus 500GB 7200.4 ST9500420AS.
    The disk is parking and spinning down in ridiculous moments, it can park itself every two seconds for ten times when I browse the web with a loud "click" and a froze the mac for a second. It helps to use hdapm and set the disk apm to max, but this is not a solution.
    This is not the beep+click issue on the unibody Macbook Pros.
    Is it a Seagate fault or the power management setting in Macbook Pro?

    Welcome to Apple Discussions!
    One thing to check is that your Seagate is not the model with the G-Force feature, which is Seagate's version of a sudden motion sensor. If your serial number is correct and there is no "G" at the end, then it should not be. If you do have the drive with the G-Force, you may need to disable Apple's built in Sudden Motion Sensor. Here are some links links where you can read about this:
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1935
    http://support.apple.com/kb/HT1934
    http://discussions.apple.com/thread.jspa?threadID=1901090&tstart=0
    Another possibility is a problem with the new drive. You can do a comprehensive check of the physical health of the drive with S.M.A.R.T. Utility:
    http://www.versiontracker.com/dyn/moreinfo/macosx/32454
    You can download the demo and run it several times for free.
    Using these links, you should be able to evaluate the Seagate drive and decide if it is the problem or not.
    Good luck!

Maybe you are looking for