IMac failures

I have tried unsuccessfully to find an email address for Apple, where I can give critical feedback about my iMac experience and expect to have some response.  The only feedback channels make it clear there will be no response and I fear it disappears into a black hole.  So I'm posting this here in the hope that someone might offer a contact e-mail or reflect on my experience.
I bought a 21.5" iMac in 2010.  Just after the end of the Applecare agreement, the DVD drive failed and had to be replaced at my expense.  Last year the screen went blank, other than grey pixellated stripes and the faint log-in icon.  Assessment by our local computer repair shop (not an official Apple retailer/repairer, but experienced in dealing with Apple issues) suggested that the graphics card (Nvidia G-force, I think) had failed, probably with the solder connections having melted as this was a problem that had been a common issue with my model/age of Mac.  Indeed, they thought that Apple had repaired this fault free within a certain period of purchase.  They suggested the most economical way of repairing this was a specialist in London, with a three month guarantee.  I took this option and 3 months and 2 weeks after the return, the same fault occurred again.
I decided enough was enough and have bought a new iMac....albeit with some annoyance and without total confidence. 
Am I just unlucky?  Am I unreasonable to think this level of component failure is unacceptable?  Apple charges a significant premium for its products (its record profits recently announced are unsurprising).  Given the quality of build and design that they presumably regard as justifying this, is a 4.5 year lifespan for an iMac the norm?  My use is purely domestic and way below the use that many Macs must experience.

Stamfordian
Yes Apple had a succession of badly designed iMacs. The white 24" iMacs were a particular problem. I had two fail with identical problems.
I also had problems with the first 24" Aluminium iMac with failed network card and power board. I insisted Apple replace it after the second repair still did not fix it.
The hard drive failed in my 27" iMac 30 days after I bought it. I was particularly upset because when I researched it, it was a known problem, but Apple did not warn me and I lost a fair amount of work.
In my long experience Macs suffer from design failures due to Apple trying to slim down the design too much, causing overheating, or because of some other unusual and unconventional technology which proves more experimental than practical. Some of their components, at least the cases, are better built and better material but otherwise Macs are not any more reliable than modern PCs which if bought from major suppliers are very durable.
Apple works hard at the myth of superiority to justify their higher prices, it is hard to get them to even talk about problems, they will just go silent unless it flares up into a major media story.
As compensation the service and support from AppleStores is good and the unified hardware/software leads to less finger pointing when you have a problem, Apple has to own the problem and fix it if it is under warranty. I have had entire units replaced if I made a clear case for it, without too much fuss.
Peter

Similar Messages

  • Drastic iMac failure Help Help!

    I switched on my iMac G5 (w/iSight) today and after the grey screen and blue screen with spinning circle, the screen turned black and i have a Darwin command line asking for login and password
    I then type in both and get multiple command line stating:
    "date/time: iMacG5 netinfo local (32) cannot lookup child"
    Is there a way to reboot with such failure?
    I am very concerned i'll be able to get that stuff working again
    Any tips, i am in
    many thanks

    Excellent
    tenks for the prompt reply
    I actually started a reinstall of the System. This is kind of radical but that might work
    if not, i'll try the suggestions in your links
    This iMac is on the way to maintenance anyway (i am sooo glad i got an Applecare plan, i already lost a HD and now my Airport card is out of order: feel kind of lucky). So I guess I have no reasons to wait any longer
    Cheers and muchas gracias

  • IMac won't power up - 3rd iMac failure...

    OK so my 3rd iMac is destined for the repairers (numbers 1 and 2 were returned direct to Apple as they failed within 2 weeks).
    It had been randomly turning itself off and on again and this got more frequent. About a week ago it wouldnt reboot for 1.5 hours and yesterday it died totally and wouldn't reboot all evening.
    There is no sound on startup, it goes to start up and fails, no screen, no noise, no nothing - and the light on the front of the display is solid white.
    Any ideas? I am SO fed up with iMacs

    welcome, Kirrianna , to the forum,
    and - whow!! -- 3 iMacs in a row with the same failure??? this sounds strange indeed! My first iMac is still running after 7.5 years, the G5 i bought 1.5 years ago has developed recently a problem, and my powerbook is running since 1 year w/o problem. Thus, you must attract bad luck, it seems.
    could it be a power problem? can u try to use stabilized power?
    about the start-up chime: if you turn off the output of the loudspeakers, there will be no sound.
    can you start from the cd?
    before I (and others) can give you some more hints, please indicate what machine you have, and what you did to get it running eventually. if the powerlight is on, something should happen...
    please, post back,
    thomas
    iMac G5, 768 MB, PB G4 12"   Mac OS X (10.3.9)   PB runs osx 10.4

  • Power Failure, now iMac failure

    Hi there,
    I have an early '09 iMac that has suffered though 5 back to back power outages and restores by the local utility. Now it won't boot into mavericks. I get the spinning gear until I shut the machine off. Attempts to boot into safe mode have the same result.
    I've tried all the typical solutions listed on the net. I've tried booting with verbose mode on, and it seems to hang up around the time bluetooth drivers are loaded up. (forgive my PC language)
    I can boot into single user mode and have checked the HDD, it checks out fine. I've also run disk utility in recovery mode and that also reports no problems. Ive also repaired permissions until no more are listed.
    The next step I tried is an Lion install disk, unfortunately I can't downgrade my OS....
    Then I tried a Time Machine restore, to no effect. Same with a new mavericks install from the apple in recovery mode.
    Here's the weird thing, I had an old WinXP install on another partition that I installed when I was running Snow Leopard, and despite Maverick's not supporting XP, I was able to boot into XP normally, by pressing "C" on startup. This leads me to believe that the problem is software related, not hardware!
    I guy I was talking to about this problem had mentioned something about a kernel rebuild or something? Does that sound familiar?
    Is there any other option that I can try aside from a complete format and re-install? I have a ton of media on this HDD that isn't backed up, and I don't have access to another mac with a firewire port.
    Help please!

    Have you tried booting while holding down the Option key?
    Startup Manager: How to select a startup volume

  • Well that didn't take long....21.5" iMac Failure

    3 days as a new iMac owner and it's already broken. So far PC/Windows wins! Just getting a white screen with an Apple logo and the activity icon spinning. Any suggestions? I was just importing photos into iPhoto and had just got used to the way iPhoto works and then everything started to freeze. Now my install CD is stuck inside the darn thing. Not a good way to start things off if Apple is going to convert this long time Windows user. Any suggestions?

    +already broken+
    Of course it's not broken. Restart and it'll be fine. Importing photos from where/what? If from another hard drive, understandable. Break the import into smaller amounts, such as importing from one user at a time, instead of all photos from all users in one session.
    Why was your install dvd in the drive, anyway? To eject it, hold down the mouse at the very beginning of startup or restart, continuing to hold down until disc ejects - it must eject.

  • Total iMac failure!  Please help.  Problems with freezing, and time machine

    My iMac has started to go crazy over the last week. It started crashing repeatedly, so much so that it could take me 10 tries just to get it going. I was able to run disk warrior and disk utility and neither of those came up with any issues. I took it into the apple store and they repaired permissions and cleared the cache and of course nothing happened while the mac was in the store.
    When I came home I started trying to clear out excess files and organize to save space and memory. I downloaded cleanmymac as well as crucial.com's scanner as recommended by the mac genius. Unfortunately, that night after everything had been working fine, the computer started crashing all over again. I get lines through my screen, it locks up, things get distorted, etc.
    In addition, I noticed today that all of my time machine backups have been deleted from my machine. The only one that exists is a huge one that was created the day after it was examined at the store. I have no idea how that happened as I have not touched the time machine settings. To make matters worse, the time machine will not even back up now. It says there isn't enough space. (There are 160GB available). Shouldn't it just be making incremental backups? All I am doing at this point is deleting files anyway!
    If anyone has any suggestions at all, please offer them!!!

    Hi, unfortunately it sounds as though your Mac needs the attentions of an Apple Service Technician.
    You do not say how old your Mac is or if you have Applecare..
    In any event I feel you will do best as I previously said -> Apple Service Technician.
    Don't forget to L I S T all your issues/worries......L

  • Migrate from pc to iMac failure

    Hi Folks,
    I'm a newbie iMac user and cannot get Migrate from PC to iMac working.
    The iMac can see shared folders on PC, but the PC cannot connect to the iMac.
    Both machines share wired router. I can ping from each machine to the other, the PC sees the iMac in the workgroup but cannot connect.
    I need Migrate to bring over 4 Outlook Express folders (mailboxes) that were left out after two attempts by the apple store to migrate my doc's, photos and email. There is a utility called "Belkin Switch-to-Mac" on both machines.
    I really need help to accomplish this hopefully one shot deal.
    Thanks,
    Peter

    Please closely follow the directions in About MS Windows Migration Assistant, if you still have difficulty then call AppleCare, you have 90 days of free telephone support. Their phone number is in your owners manual. AppleCare can assist with the Apple side of things however remember they are not there to support networking on PCs. If you still have trouble you may need to visit a AASP or Apple Store.
    You will need to study how to turn on file sharing on your PC, it's possible but as I recall on XP it was a little tricky.

  • March 08 software updates trigger iMac failure?

    I just got back from a trip, turned on my iMac G5, came back with some coffee and saw "software updates are available for your computer - install now?" So I unplugged everything (old habit), said yes, and clicked on "restart" when it asked. The computer did the install, restarted, and came back on with no startup chime, no slot-loading CD drive noise, no monitor activity, and the fans running at 100%. I let it sit for a couple hours, still no change. After pressing and holding the power button to shut it off, I unplugged the machine from power (PMU reset procedure) and attempted to reboot. No luck.
    Since then I've tried
    - boot into Target disk mode: same symptoms, no FWTDM at all
    - boot from CD: same symptoms, drive will not make a startup noise nor suck in a CD. Using original disks and/or Disk Warrior 4.1.
    - boot into safe mode: same symptoms. Have tried wired and wireless keyboards both verified to work with other macs.
    Next I'm going to try taking out the 2GB Ram and replacing the original Ram, but I don't expect that to change things for the better. The computer was working fine under the old RAM for at least 4 months prior to these software updates.
    SO, any other suggestions? I've been using macs since 1988 and am considered the resident Apple Genius, but this one has me stumped. My iMac is a Rev B which has had the power supply and hard drive replaced on apple care. All the latest updates, regular care and feeding with Disk Utility, OnyX and Disk Warrior, backups with Time Machine, etc.

    The saga continues. The iMac would not restart after either a shutdown, restart, or sleep cycle. I opened it back up, removed and replaced the RAM, and it started fine. But would not restart - just a black screen, no startup chime, and 100% fan speed.
    I removed the back and put it right back on - no other hardware changes. Same sequence: good first boot, failed subsequent boots.
    I unscrewed the back, DIDN'T move it AT ALL, screwed it back together, and same sequence: good first boot. Very strange. The iMac must have a continuity check that involves the three screws. When the screws get backed out, the circuit must get broken and trigger something.
    So I ran the OS X 10.5.2 combo updater over top of the existing 10.5.2 install. After the install was complete, I got a little message that said the computer needed to update Boot Cache files and restart. Crossing my fingers, I clicked OK.
    So far no problems. My guess is that there is a hardware override of boot cache after the case is opened. Then on subsequent reboots without a hardware config change (actual or assumed by a screw movement), the system looks for the boot cache. The recent updates corrupted those files or something in the process, making the mac hang. By over-installing the combo update, I forced the boot caches into a usable format again.
    The phantom part is shown in this photo. (Right click and open in new window to see bigger). The offending part and gapping are both on the power button and peripheral port side of the computer (left when viewed from the back). It looks like a printed circuit board held on by a hard drive mounting screw: .
    The right side is perfectly flush as it's supposed to be. The case warping on the left side is shown in this photo: .
    Any thoughts?

  • Start-Up from external hard-drive with Time Machine

    I am using a 500GB Firewire/USB-2 external drive as my back-up, using Time Machine. I've looked all over (and read Bob Levitus's book) for an answer:
    How do I set up this external drive to automatically boot, in the event of internal drive (iMac) failure?
    I've looked in the preferences for Time Machine, but don't see anything, and am not sure how to set this up, if necessary. Would my iMac automatically look for and resort to another drive, if the main drive failed?
    Thanks

    Time Machine backups aren't bootable until restored with the Time Machine application on a Mac OS X install DVD or installation or migrated from following setting up an OS manually. A Time Machine backup drive can be partitioned to include a Mac OS X system, but as before, the backed up system needs to be restored before it can be booted from.
    (50848)

  • IPod as backup for my photo and music library

    May I use iPod as backup device for my photo and music library in case of my iMac failure? Is this tested and recommended solution?
    Thanks, Jan

    This is an extremely risky option because when (and not if) there comes a time to restore your iPod, which is a very common fix for iPod problems, then all the music/photos would be erased. If you no longer have them in iTunes (or any other back up), then all that music and other data would be lost.
    What if the iPod were lost/stolen/needed repair? Again, the music would lost. I strongly recommend a different form of back up, and if computer hard drive space is in short supply, you should seriously consider an external hard drive. They are not expensive, and the cost is well worth it when compared to the loss of all your precious music and photos.
    At the very least back up your music/photos to either cd or dvd before deleting them, particularly any purchased music/videos, as this would have to be bought again if it were lost. See this.
    Backing up your media in iTunes.

  • USB Flash Drive Help

    Hi gang,
    I'm not sure if this is the correct place to ask this question, but it's the closest forum I could find.
    I have an old iMac running Mac OS 8.6, and I need to transfer some files (Appleworks documents, and family pictures) from it to another iMac running OS 10.3.9. They are in different locations, with only dial-up internet access, so I can't transfer files over the internet (easily), or by an ethernet connection.
    I have two USB flash drives. The first is an old 128 MB, USB 1.1 drive. The other is an 8 GB, USB 2.0 drive. Neither drive will work on the OS 8.6 machine. When I put the device in the USB port, I get a message:
    +'The software needed to use the USB device "USB Drive" cannot be found. Please refer to the device documentation to install the necessary software.'+
    The 128 MB drive is so old, I don't have any documentation. I tried looking on the website of the manufacturer for a drive, or something, (the flash drive says Fujifilm on it), but they don't have anything useful.
    The 8 GB drive is newer, but didn't come with any instructions or installers (not that I was counting on it to work on this old machine). It's a Verbatim flash drive, and they didn't have any help there.
    I tried re-formatting the 128 MB drive to Mac OS Standard. That didn't work. I tried formatting it in Mac OS Extended HFS+. That didn't work.
    My question is this, is there a software extension that I could download, it can't be that large of a file for dial-up, that would allow me to use the flash drive on a computer using OS 8.6? I have an OS 9 CD, and I also have a back-up CD of OS 9.2.1. Is it possible there is a driver in the extensions folder there that I could transfer and use in OS 8.6?
    I appreciate any and all help.
    Thank you.
    just a rambling joe

    Hi, joe -
    ...I'm going to replace this iMac's 4GB hard drive with a slightly larger one...
    If your iMac has a processor speed less than 350MHz, it is important that you partition the new drive if it is 8GB or larger -
    Article #TA22193 - Gray or White Screen After Hard Drive Upgrade
    Article #TA20420 - OSX: Disk Appears "Grayed Out" in Installer
    ...install OS 10.3.9 and OS 9.2...
    Important - before attempting to install OSX be sure the firmware has been updated on the iMac; failure to do so can cause loss of video on early iMac models -
    Article #HT1395 - Firmware Updates

  • Firewire not on profiler

    I have an iMac. I was doing an OS X and security update. When I went to 'restart" the computer would not get past the white page gear wheel. I called Apple, and was walked through a reboot with my startup disc by a specialist (it took a while). That part worked OK.
    But, I had two external drives on firewire. One of them came on line. the other one did not. I changed cables. But the second drive still did not come up. Is it possible the original iMac failure to reboot caused a problem with this drive?
    I am about ready to take the drive to a data recovery firm and see if the data can be retrieved. I am hoping there is a simple correction before I do this expensive move..
    Seagate was of little help.

    Ah! Then may aI suggest you repost in the forums for Intel iMacs here:
    http://discussions.apple.com/category.jspa?categoryID=189
    This forum, for the older G4 iMacs with the "desk-lamp" monitor arm and hemi base, is poorly labeled and commonly leads owners of newer iMacs to the wrong spot.

  • Multiple iMac LogicBoard failures

    So 3 years ago I took the plunged and converted the house to Macs. Nice experience generally. Yet in the last 2 months I have had two logicboard failures on two iMacs. The cost to fix these was quoted at over $1,000 each computer. Obviously given the age of the machines, this is not a viable fix.
    I am now considering moving back to PC's (my 3 year old Mac laptop is also playing up).
    After logicboard failure #1, I reluctantly forked out $2K for a new machine. I racked this up as a "bad" and unusual unit. #2 comes along and fails and it makes me mad. Worse, no sympathy from the guys in the Apple Store. I ask "Surely for a machine of this age, noone would possibly pay for a $1K logicboard? Isn't this priced to basically make you buy a new machine?" All I got back was smiles (they really didn't care it seems).
    Question:
    - Are Mac's prone to hardware failures?
    - If they do get hardware failures are you basically just in trouble given the absurd component prices to fix ($700 for the logicboard part alone)? How can Apple justify $700 for a logicboard part?
    - Does Apple offer any discounts to people who have had these multiple bad experiences? (I'm partly kidding here, but also hoping)
    My Mac laptop is playing up so I may be two Mac's down. I am considering going back to the darkside now and buying PC's again.
    Anyone got any comments?
    Thanks

    That a UPS unit would have prevented your logic board failures. Properly designed power supplies do not need a UPS unit in this country. In some third world countries where the power is unreliable on a daily basis with large power swings, they are a must have.
    In my opinion, the G5 iMac's were a poor design with inadequate heat dissipation, weak power supplies and logic boards. Most of them ran for years, but an inordinate number of them had multiple failures. The new aluminum models are a much better design with most of the high heat components located at the top of the machine.
    I had no hardware problems with my eight year old Dell...but I'm still sticking with Apple because of their superior software performance.
    Good luck with what ever you decide...virg

  • I had a failure of a dsl modem which inturn destroyed my ethernet port of non isight imac G5.  In attempt to solve the problem I did a clean install of leopard 10.5.4. I am unable to upate to 10.6,.7  or .8 without freezing system network preferences

    Dsl modem failure caused malfunction of ethernet port.  In attempt to solve problem I did a clean instillation of  Leopard 10.5.4 and then update to 10.5.5 with access to internet through apple usb to ethernet adapter.  If I attempt to update software to 10.5.6, .7 or .8 it freezes my network system preferences and computer will no longer shut down.  The network connection assistant also no longer sees a connection to the internet throught the usb/ethernet adapter.  I have checked they systerm Tech tool deluxe which shows no problems and also used hard drive utility on instillation disk which found no problems.  Permissions were also checked as well and no problems noted.  Any thoughts as I really like my imac G5.

    Could be many things, we should start with this...
    "Try Disk Utility
    1. Insert the Mac OS X Install disc, then restart the computer while holding the C key.
    2. When your computer finishes starting up from the disc, choose Disk Utility from the Installer menu at top of the screen. (In Mac OS X 10.4 or later, you must select your language first.)
    *Important: Do not click Continue in the first screen of the Installer. If you do, you must restart from the disc again to access Disk Utility.*
    3. Click the First Aid tab.
    4. Select your Mac OS X volume.
    5. Click Repair Disk, (not Repair Permissions). Disk Utility checks and repairs the disk."
    http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=106214
    Then try a Safe Boot, (holding Shift key down at bootup), run Disk Utility in Applications>Utilities, then highlight your drive, click on Repair Permissions, reboot when it completes.
    (Safe boot may stay on the gray radian for a long time, let it go, it's trying to repair the Hard Drive.)
    If perchance you can't find your install Disc, at least try it from the Safe Boot part onward.
    If all the above fails, then it appears to be time for a relatively painless Archive & Install, which gives you a new/old OS, but can preserve all your files, pics, music, settings, etc., as long as you have plenty of free disk space and no Disk corruption, and is relatively quick & painless...
    http://docs.info.apple.com/article.html?artnum=107120
    Just be sure to select Preserve Users & Settings.

  • Imminent hard drive failure 2010 iMac 27, 2.93GHz

    Hi I have a 2010 2.93GHz 27in iMac that is my main machine. It has both a 256GB Apple SSD and a 2TB Hitachi HDS722020ALA330 installed with the SSD running Apps and the system and the Hitachi used for my Home folder.
    I use both iStat and SMART Utility to monitor the condition of both drives since a sudden failure by either would be catastrophic. I have an adequate back-up procedure in place but I don't want to be suddenly pressurised to replace either drive hurriedly in an emergency. Call it being prepared...
    Anyhow, SMART Utility is warning me of imminent failure of the Hitachi drive containing all my data. However iStat passes both using SMART status. So which do I believe?
    Looking online it seems that SMART Utility has a pretty good track record in detecting possible failures but I guess unlesss you actually wait for it to happen you can never be sure if the diagnosis is correct.
    So I decided to prepare for the worst by ordering a Western Digital 4TB Caviar Black. I like WD and I like the five year warranty even more, however when it arrived I tried to format it. It was noisy spinning up and Disk Utility would not allow a format to take place even though it did actually see it in the list of drives.
    I have since found out that internal drives on some iMacs must be replaced with those from identical brands - in my case Hitachi. Hitachi is now called HGST and guess who owns it - yup, Western Digital...
    So, the supposed reason for needing an identical branded hard drive is to enable the temperature sensors to work avoiding the 'full-on fan experience'. In the past I have fitted other brand hard drives to other iMacs and used HDD Fan Control to get around the issue but this is my own machine and I intend hanging on to it in as close to factory condition as I can. It's simply the best Mac I have owned in 20 years!
    HDD Fan Control has worked very well but obviously I don't want to go down the road of stripping my main machine unneccessarily nor encountering compatibility or other problematic issues that further delay fixing the drive keeping my machine unavailable for work.
    And there's the rub. It isn't yet a problem according to iStat. So which software should I believe and which 4TB hard drive should I buy to maintain an otherwise happy Apple experience with my beloved 2010 iMac?
    Thanks for any helpful advice!
    Rich

    Run Apple Hardware Test in extended mode 2-3 times back to back. If any errors appear then take the machine in immediately and get the machine fixed. If errors appear that only confirms a hardware  problem is imminent however if  no errors appear you may still have troubles.
    You left your profile completely blank, it would be helpful if you read Help us to help you on these forums so you know what we look for to assist you.
    I would also recommend running Repair Disk in Disk Utility on the internal HD,  because you did not complete a profile we don't even know the version of OS X you have running so we cannot offer more instruction than that. If Repair Disk reports errors then yes take it in immediately for replacement.

Maybe you are looking for