Exporting via Quicktime good Compressor=Bad

I'm perplexed! I send a 16:9 video SD out through Compressor and when i import that file into DVDstudio pro, it's 4:3 aspect.
Exporting through a self contained QT file and importing into DVD studio it retains its 16:9.
Why does this happen???

What preset or settings did you use in Compressor?
-DH

Similar Messages

How can I export via QuickTime in iMovie '13 (10.0)?

Prior versions of iMovie had an export via QuickTime option, which allowed me to select the file format, encoding settings, etc. After upgrading to the new iMovie, that appears to have gone away. The Share -> File option does not allow me that level of control over the output file. Has that functionality been removed from iMovie?

I'm also having trouble with this. The new version of iMovie lost a lot of its features and is clearly focused toward the social media side of things. After importing using SD cameras that import video in a *square* PiP format, I am finding it impossible to update any of my settings to export the video in any other format that wouldn't cut out the picture. Basically, the only settings I've found in the share option of the iMovie 10.0 cu off the tops and bottoms of all my recording. Previously, I used QuickTime settings to pick what format and quality I wanted to export in. Does anyone have any insight about how to export using, say, a 640 x 480 format or in being able to adjust to any format other than the standard ones giving.
Is there any other video software I can be using to import and export with that gives me more functionality?

Export via Motion or Compressor?

I have a 2-minute motion graphics video that I put together in Motion 3. I want to export it for the web (YouTube, etc.) and so I'm using H.264. Assuming I'm not getting into Compressor's fancy batching / clustering features, are there any advantages to exporting via Compressor as opposed to direct from Motion?
Thanks,
Scott

You haven't said if the original video you imported into Motion is MP4 or H.264 or some other highly compressed media. It won't matter what you export if those "damaged" frames are in the original (and mp4/h.264/etc are prone to bad frames at the very beginning and very end depending on how they were prep'd for delivery).
You should (I'd say always, except I'd be a hypocrite) transcode original media into ProRes (any flavor) before importing into Motion. Check frame by frame if you have to to see if there's any damaged frames (usually there won't be.) I'd highly recommend using Quicktime 7 Pro (it's still available from apple's online store at apple.com) to transcode your video. Others might recommend MPEGStreamclip (but I just can't); or if you have it: Compressor.
If you have Final Cut Pro X, you'd be better off editing video in that app. You should be designing your Motion "add-ons" as effects, titles, transitions or generators for use in FCPX and leaving the video completely out of Motion. FCPX also takes care of transcoding to prores for you (opt to Transcode Optimized Media when importing.)
PS - you'll get better performance out of Motion if you use ProRes video. (Same goes for AIFF/WAV audio and NOT mp3.)
Hope this helps... otherwise I don't know what the problem would be.

Export as quicktime vs compressor?

need to export a couple sequences. they are apple prores hq 720p. want to export w/ same settings as sequence. other than batching, is there any advantage to using compressor as opposed to export as quicktime movie from fcp? seems to take a lot longer using compressor. thanks.

"Seems to take longer" may not be correct if you let it run all the way to completion.
The advantages are numerous if you understand how to use Compressor's advanced functions including frame settings and distributed encoding. If you don't need them, don't use Compressor.
We see a similar post every few weeks so you can search the forum for additional information that I'm not providing.
bogiesan

Export via Quicktime Slow

Hi,
I am having a problem with exporting videos via Quicktime. Instead of taking all the cores on the Mac Pro it seems to take only ~10% of all the cores.
Is there a setting in iMovie that would allow me to actually make real use of all the 8 cores in the Mac Pro instead of having to wait 5+ hours for an hour of video to be encoded?

Michael Kalus wrote:
.. Is there a setting in iMovie that would allow me to actually make real use of all the 8 cores in the Mac Pro instead of having to wait 5+ hours for an hour of video to be encoded?
No.
iLife apps use only one core.
don't expect wonders from a 20$ app..
probably 'Grand Central', a feature of SnowLeopard http://www.apple.com/macosx/snowleopard/ , adds multi-core support..

Exporting via Compressor - submit - failed

When I use Export via Compressor - and I use QT Pro Res - and destination is Movies Folder, then submit - then in the History window it has returned "Failed" 3 times now. The status bar shows, but never any indication that it even starts to work its magic or anything - just after a few seconds, maybe a minute, the word Failed appears. Argh. The motn project is 5 minutes long full of stills and a little video with audio. Help - what am I doing wrong?
In looking thru this forum, I thot the best export would be QT ProRes - is that causing the failure?
I previously exported via QT(not compressor) and the resulting file is 10gb which doesn't run smoothly but jerks and hiccups like a pre-rendered file. And 10gb wont fit onto DVD which is where this project will go - as a gift.
help

I surely do not take it personal. I have learned that you folks in this group are the best resource I have. I know I am in way over my head. I truly do not know about codecs.
I have taken Motion directly in to FCP - but I didn't think it would work this time. I should have tried.
Someone came along at work and told me to use Visual Hub and use setting for mp4, and also try using the DV - ready for FCP - I did both. I really never think of it as wasted effort if I can learn by what I doing, and that is occurring as you are all explaining to me what I should be doing.
Now as for workflow - I think I did the right thing by starting with Motion, then with the big file sizes went to Visual Hub - but probably could have just gone to opening the Motion files in FCP - then rendering out for DVSP.
System settings are a boggle to me - so I just use NTSC - DV 720x480 and hope that works - so far the results in my projects are good.
Again, Thank you for taking time to explain - I appreciate all comments.

Export to Compressor or Export to Quicktime then into Compressor

Hi,
Already for a long I am wondering whether it would make a significant difference when you export video directly to compressor from FCP or indirectly via Quicktime to Compressor. If you have any experience regarding this, please let me no know.
Thank you

The main difference is that using the Export Using Compressor method, Compressor will look at the original format & framerate of each clip in your sequence and will render out based upon that. So if you have some higher quality clips in your sequence, Compressor will take that into consideration when producing the final encode. It could actually give you a slightly better quality picture.
If you were to export a movie first, then run that through Compressor, Compressor only sees the one file and one format.
MacBreak weekly produced a small episode that explains how Compressor works in this manner. It should answer your question.
http://www.pixelcorps.tv/macbreak89

Cannot export to quicktime or send to youtube

Hi All,
This is a new problem. I have been doing this for months with no issue until this month.
It seems to have started when a preso I sent to youtube only went up partly. Instead of the full 20 minutes or so, it only took the first minute and a half. However, no error messages were returned. I actually assumed it all worked fine till one of my viewers pointed out it was cut short.
For the next preso I did, I just started getting an error message that the disk was full or the video file was bad. This happens when trying to send to youtube. I tried exporting via quicktime, but the resulting file ends up with no sound and is clearly causing quicktime some trouble. Quicktime menus slow to respond and quicktime just seems to be working hard on something when it should not be. It does NOT do this with other quicktime movies I have that have come from other sources. Then sometimes, exporting to quicktime will result in the same error I got when sending to youtube.
Any ideas on what the heck is going on here?
R

Ok guys, here is the solution.
The culprit is Quicktime 7.5
I took my system back to 7.4 and now find everything is working fine.
Here is a link to an article that outlines the process. It is basically as easy as downloading "Pacifist" and the Quicktime 7.4.5 installer. But this article gives the details.
The Article:
http://www.macfixit.com/article.php?story=20080617143056579
Good Luck,
R
Message was edited by: Robert Whitelaw

Export using QuickTime...

Hello,
I recently started my second video project for my family which is converting Video8 and Hi8 tapes to digital video and had a few questions regarding "Export using QuickTime".
I utilize a Digital8 camcorder to play my analog Video8 and Hi8 tapes with a DV FireWire cable so the camera does the analog to DV conversion when importing into iMovie 09. Next, I utilize the MPEG Streamclip to do the DV clip conversion using 720 x 480 (DV-NTSC) frame size settings and apply contrast & color alternations. Lastly, I import the new .mov clips into iMovie, create a new project, do some trimming and now ready to export.
Question: I don't plan to share to iTunes, iDVD, Media Browser, YouTube or MobileMe Gallery however I would like to export and put the video on a media center device. That leaves me with "Export with Quicktime" however there are quite a few export options, for example:
Movie to AVI
Movie to DV Stream
Movie to QuickTime Movie
Which export option is best to use in terms of no loss of video and audio?
Also, there is additional settings, Options button, to configure video settings (compression, frame rate, data rate, quality, dimensions) and sound settings (format, channels and sample rate & size). Are these settings or defaults good to go out-of-the-box or do I need to tweak?
Any experiences or recommendations on export options and video and sound settings would be appreciated.
Thanks,
Dave

"DV will import just fine into iMovie 09 however when you render or export, iMovie uses 'single field processing' meaning every other horizontal line of the video is thrown out. In effect, reduces the sharpness of the footage. By using MPEG Streamclip, I am converting it into another format and then importing it back into iMovie."
I'm aware of the problem and I'm very curious about your solution. How exactly do you avoid the field drop issue? I thought you said you went from DV back to DV, which I thought would not have any effect on the field issue. Most other reports of working around the issue involve de-interlacing with, eg. JES Deinterlacer.
"Format: H.264, 640 x 480, Millions
Format: AAC, 2 channels, 44100 Hz
FPS: 29.97"
These are the AppleTV export defaults I guess? You could accomplish the same thing by an export via Quicktime, and then you'll get more control. IMHO, Apple's presets were chosen to produce "pretty good" quality at small file sizes. That's certainly a reasonable approach and they probably made a very well calculated compromise. But my preference is to sacrifice time and disk space to eke out a bit more image quality if I can.
Either way, these settings are very close to what I would use anyway, if your original video is 640 x 480. I thought my SD camcorder gave a bit more resolution before it croaked. Sorry I can't check it right now. Just be sure you're not losing resolution in the process. You could also bump the audio to 48 kHz if the input audio is at that sample rate. In the QT export, the other thing you can adjust is quality level; the default for AppleTV is probably "Good" or "Better" and single pass compression. Choosing "Best" multi-pass compression will take longer and give you a bigger file. You'll have to judge whether it's worth it. And just because you can see things on your monitor doesn't mean you'll see it on your TV - you have to test.
It's frustrating, but there really is no right answer to all this stuff, because the choices you make depend on your source and your display, and everything in between.

Advantage of exporting using Quicktime?

Just a quick question, what's the advantage of exporting via Quicktime vs. iMovie?

It is all the same. iMovie uses QuickTime.
iMovie provides pre-sets that are useful for most purposes.
The chief advantage of Sharing using QuickTime is you have a lot of flexibility.
I use it when
1) I want to share in a codec other than h.264.
2) I want to share a movie as audio only
3) In older versions of iMovie, there was no 1080P pre-set, so I would export 1080P through this setting.

Export from FCP via QT or Compressor into DVD Studio Pro?

Hi everyone,
I'm editing in FCP and making a menued SD DVD. I've had success in laying out the DVD project.
The source material is low quality and duration overall a few minutes. I'm adding a few supers to the clips.
My question is, will I get better result exporting via compressor or via a QT export (using current settings PAL 25FPS 16:9)?
Thanks in advance.
Steve

what you're doing is actually fine. But, generally, the following workflow is reccommended. It gives you more control if not better quality. Depending on your source (large or small frame size) you can adjust resizing and motion compensation and other parameters:
export as QuickTime using "current settings." bring that resulting QT file into Compressor. Pick the DVD preset closest to the length of your project (e.g. 90 min best). From there you can select the preset in the project and adjust it.

Re user tip: How can I import a homemade DVD into iMovie for editing? - I've followed instructions so far so good, until I get to "You can then FILE/EXPORT USING QUICKTIME and choose Apple Intermediate Codec as your video codec. " How do I do that?

Re AppleMan 1958 excellent user tip: How can I import a homemade DVD into iMovie for editing? -
I've followed instructions with success until "You can then FILE/EXPORT USING QUICKTIME and choose Apple Intermediate Codec as your video codec. " How do I do that?
I installed MGEG Streamclip 193b8 and used their utility to install quicktimempeg2 and got a message stating it was successfully installed. (I'm on latest Maverick 10.9.2 on iMac) Then I dragged the VIDEO_TS file from my home DVD into the streamclip app. It asked which of 4 files to use, and I selected the first one. Streamclip played the video with the sound. so far so good. but now I cannot figure how to use quicktime player 10.3 to export this vob file out of streamclip.

Thank you for your quick reply and for clearing up my confusion. I'm exporting the first section now. I choose the smallest size, 3x4 but I'd prefer to go higher as this DVD was originally a VHS home movie. I'm wondering if after three conversions (VHS,->DVD->MPEG) the resolution will be so poor as to not support a larger size frame? If it can, what size should I select when I export?

Compressor vs. Export Using Quicktime

Hi, all. I need to export a movie from FCP as a Quicktime movie for web streaming. Should I Export "Using Compressor" or the "Using Quicktime Conversion?" I can't find a reason to use one over the other in all the Apple documentation. So what is the difference between the two? Why use one or the other? Any help would be greatly appreciated. Thanks.

i use the "export to quicktime movie" if i'm going to recompress to many different formats. i.e. i export the full quality version and then run that through compressor to create hd, sd, web, and dvd versions for viewing.
exporting straight to compressor is useful when exporting a lot of sequences to web etc...

Exported Project via Quicktime Conversion-Some scenes "tear" at the top

I have completed a 17 min project made up mostly of photo/stills. Some have motion added some dont---it doesn't seem to matter to my problem: when I exported the project using Quick Time Conversion I noticed as I checked it prior to using iDVD to burn it to DVD that during cross dissolves and some other transitions there was a "digitized tearing" or pixels slow in locking into place in the upper 1/5th or so of the screen. I had not noticed this problem in previewing the rendered project prior to export. Using FCE v3.5HD. Anyone seen this problem? Is there a problem with some of the transitions or was it something that occurred in the export? I tried to burn to DVD via iDVD so I could see if the problem was off the top of the screen, but apprently I did something wrong during use of iDVD. When the iMac ejected the DVD after burn, I tried playing on a set-top and it wouldn't play, nor could I get it to play in the iMac. I also had difficulty getting the iMac to eject this DVD.

It sounds as if you have multiple problems here. The first problem is that QuickTime Conversion is not the way to export to iDVD. You should export to QuickTime Movie.

Should I export via Export Movie, or Export using Quicktime?

Hello,
I am making a "yearly video" of our family video clips. The movie is 45 minutes long. I have an HD camcorder though I have uploaded all the video as "large" as suggested since I dont have a Bluray burner anyway. I know how to export as a DVD file, but if I just want to create my movie to play on my computer, what is the optimal way to do it where I loose the least quality? This way I can save the file for later, should a better "burning" situation come about in a year or two. Should I export movie as "HD" or use "Export using quicktime" or some other option?
Thank you!!

Sorry.
By all DVDs until the master, I mean any preview copies that are used to preview content only, not video quality.
I export a reference movie, which means a movie file that refers to all render and media files on my drives, instead of creating a new self-contained quicktime movie. By using a reference movie, I save drive space (they're much smaller). But reference movies will only work on a machine that contains all the media and render files.
I've used reference movies in Sorenson Squeeze before, so they may work in BitVice as well. But I much prefer Compressor to any other option.

Exporting via Quicktime good Compressor=Bad

Similar Messages

Maybe you are looking for